Fans discuss baseball players who appeared on the show, mentioning Bette Midler, Danny Tartabull, and Mickey Mantle from a fantasy camp episode.
The Understudy
Aired Thursday, May 18, 1995 · 30 min

Jerry begins to date a girl who is an understudy for Bette Midler in her new Broadway musical, Rochelle, Rochelle. Jerry, George and Kramer all play on the Improv softball team and happen to be playing against the cast and crew of Rochelle, Rochelle. Kramer fawns over Bette and Jerry's girlfriend cries about her frankfurter falling on the ground but not about her grandmother dying.
The morning after
No live reaction was captured for this episode.
Over the years
Viewers identify the episode where Elaine first meets J. Peterman, with most confirming it's "The Understudy" airing the next day.
George won The Contest, which he later references to help him get a job.
Fans discuss a baseball continuity error in "The Understudy" where George appears to be safe at home despite not touching the plate, and debate whether George or Jerry won "The Contest."
Fans discuss the timeline of Frank Costanza's affair with a Korean woman, debating whether it occurred before or after his marriage to Estelle.
Fans help transcriber identify unclear words from The Understudy script, specifically dialogue about Peterman's jacket description.
Fans debate whether George should have been called out for running over the catcher in the Bette Midler episode, with discussion of baseball and softball rules about collisions at home plate.
Fans debate Bette Midler's talent and appeal after her appearance in the episode; original poster expresses strong dislike while others defend her acting and singing abilities.
Viewers discuss Frank Costanza's various professions throughout the series, including his time selling religious items from Korea.
UK viewers report that Paramount has stopped airing The Understudy episode despite previously broadcasting it, and Paramount claims to have never shown it.
Fans discuss a moment where Jerry makes an aside to the camera about telling someone they stink, with debate over whether he was addressing the audience or making a meta-comment about the show itself.
Fans discuss what Italian ice is, clarifying that it's a frozen dessert similar to sorbet rather than slush, and noting regional naming variations like "water ice" in Philadelphia.
Viewers discuss a scene where Kramer runs through New York to get pineapple Italian ice for Bette Midler during a baseball game, debating whether it was a movie spoof and what its purpose was.
Fans discuss continuity errors in "The Understudy" episode, including George not stepping on home plate when called safe and apparent stunt doubles catching Bette Midler during a fall scene.