George was out!

S06E24 The UnderstudyretroApr 29, 199612 months later13 posts by 12 posters
🧠 Theory Came true

George won The Contest, which he later references to help him get a job.

Fans discuss a baseball continuity error in "The Understudy" where George appears to be safe at home despite not touching the plate, and debate whether George or Jerry won "The Contest."

13 posts
Budgie

Sorry if this has been covered before, but in the Bette Midler episode, the ump says that George is safe at home as he crashes into Bette. Not only was he "tagged" (although she does drop the ball), but he never even touches home plate! :0

Ron

Everytime we try to impose order we create chaos. We create chaos--breakdown. I have my doubt; a state of eternal conflict is all I have found. We build a wall that is made of tears, watch the house fall down...and at the end of my life...yes, at the end of my life...all shall be well...all is as it was always meant to be... (Killing Joke)

Sorry, didn't see all of that episode, but if she did drop the ball then George would be safe assuming he did eventually touch base (I assume he could have because Midler was incapacitated then wasn't she?) The catcher has to retain posession of the ball after contact at home.

And I thought this posting was going to be about the great "Who won The Contest?" debate. Because it's obvious after seeing the episode again tonight that it was purposely left ambiguous whether George or Jerry was out first.

In article , [email] (Whitney Pape) wrote:

George won the contest. In a later episode he uses this to help him get a job. I can't remember if this was his Yankees job or not. He is asked something like... "Are you in control of yourself?" He answers back something like..."Yes I am, I won a contest once." I wish I could remember that show

True he says that, but his whole life is a lie. He may have just been saying that since he was in the contest and wanted to make a point; so went off that....... Possibly?

Just a little note to consider :)

--Todd

It was The Puffy Shirt episode when George is interviewing for a job as a hand model. I don't remember the exact details but the employer stated that the last time he saw a pair of hands that were that nice were on a professional hand model who eventually ruined his hands by doing "you know", as George puts it, too often. Then George pipes up with "You don't have to worry about me! I won a contest!"

It's the episode where George gets hired as a hand model. The people who hire him are concerned that he might damage his hands if he...gives in to temptation. This is when he mentions that he "won a contest."

--Mike

*~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~*
*    Michael S. Rosenberg    | He had that rare weird electricity about      *
*           <*>              | him--that extremely wild and heavy presence   *
* Dept of Ecology & Evolution| that you only see in a person who has         *
*      SUNY: Stony Brook     | abandoned all hope of ever behaving normally. *
*                            |           Hunter S. Thompson                  *
*  [email]   |                    "Fear and Loathing '72"    *
*~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~*
http://life.bio.sunysb.edu/ee/msr/msr.html

In article , [email] (Kurt Sims) writes:

a

George won - and it was referenced when he got the job as a hand model. He was on a job for a watch ad, the the photographer was commenting that he hadn't seen hands since so-and-so was in the business. When George asked what happened to him, they explained that his hand cramped-up when "entertaining himself" and wasn't the same since. George said it couldn't happen to him - he won a contest!

tflintReenier

But jsut think about the kind of person that George is. He would lie about something like that!!!!! Their was no indication in the Contest episode that George or Jerry won!!!! Janine

As far as which of Jerry and George won the contest,

GIVEN: In that episode, it's clear that they both cracked the same evening.

GIVEN: When he's a hand model, George tells his boss that 'you don't have to worry about that with me. I won a contest.'

Two possibilities suggest themselves:

1) The next morning, when George and Jerry first meet, Jerry would probably be the first one to mention that he's out, and George is just enough of a dishonorable guy that he would keep his mouth shut and collect the money.

2) If they agree it was a tie, then George is walking out of there with a hundred and twenty-five dollars, and for George, that's enough to make him feel like a winner.

As far as which of Jerry and George won the contest,

GIVEN: In that episode, it's clear that they both cracked the same evening.

GIVEN: When he's a hand model, George tells his boss that 'you don't have to worry about that with me. I won a contest.'

Two possibilities suggest themselves:

1) The next morning, when George and Jerry first meet, Jerry would probably be the first one to mention that he's out, and George is just enough of a dishonorable guy that he would keep his mouth shut and collect the money.

2) If they agree it was a tie, then George is walking out of there with a hundred and twenty-five dollars, and for George, that's enough to make him feel like a winner.

I think that after he loses the virgin, Jerry shrugs off the contest and heads to the window to cave in. (He does seem to have a what the hell attitude at that point). I then presume that Jerry and George settle it off camera, leaving George as the winner, although they deliberately keep it from the viewer until the hand-modelling job.

That's how I see it, anyway if George says he won the contest, he surely can't be lying! ;)

Mike

	it was before his yankee's job.  that's when he was going to be
the hand model.  he was replacing a guy who wasn't in control of him
slef.  becase the other guy's hand "was frozen in a twisted claw, he
tried threapy, but it didn't help"
	that was also with the "low talker"