Season 1 DVD: Pops in audio on episodes 1-6!

Nov 13, 2002, 3:56 PM ET8 posts by 4 postersalt.tv.southpark
8 posts
Deadalt.tv.southpark

Hey dudes,

I just checked my new South Park Season 1 DVD and episodes 1-6 have frequent and very noticeable pops throughout them in the audio. I bought mine at BestBuy in Toronto, Canada. I'm wondering if I got a defective copy or if anyone else has this. They seem to stop after episode 6 but I haven't checked every episode on disc 3. Thanks for reading...

-Sean

Chris Shepard↩ Deadalt.tv.southpark

I actually have noticed this as well. Also the false advertsing concerning the since deleted commentary is goddamn pissing me off!

http://www.mp3.com/sierradogromeo

Onkyo tx-595 reciever running in pro logic II mode had the same problems, I was worried it was the reciever since I just bought it.

--Nick

"Chris Shepard" wrote in message news:[email]...

Dead↩ kasanova11alt.tv.southpark

On Thu, 14 Nov 2002 07:14:43 -0800, "kasanova11" wrote:

I've talked to another person who swears his has no pops. I think there was a defective batch. I've tried mine on both my DVD player and DVDRom. The pops always occur in the same places. They are quite loud and very noticeable/distracting.

Dead↩ Deadalt.tv.southpark

On Sat, 16 Nov 2002 06:03:40 GMT, Bugaboo wrote:

Thanks for the info, I appreciate it. Now to decide whether I should get an exchange or just try to get a refund.

-Sean

Dead↩ Deadalt.tv.southpark

On Sat, 16 Nov 2002 06:53:20 GMT, Dead wrote:

Well I returned it to Best Buy today, explained that it was a poor quality item and that I would like a refund or credit, as I was not convinced that an exchange would solve the problem. She checked around and said that I had to take an exchange and then if the second copy had a problem I could get a refund. I asked if they would give me a problem when I came back the second time, and she wrote a note on my receipt authorizing a refund if the second copy was bad. I came home, faintly hoping for no pops... Same exact pops in the same exact spots. Oh well. No South Park for me.. :(

I can't believe what crappy quality the audio is. I ripped one of the episodes and took a look at the audio track in CoolEdit, you can actually see tons of pops in the waveform without even zooming in.

Mike↩ Deadalt.tv.southpark

Two copies from Best Buy and they both have pops and clicks. Horroible quality control. Guess the VCR recordings are good enough!

Dead wrote in message news:...

Dead↩ Mikealt.tv.southpark

On 21 Nov 2002 13:48:13 -0800, [email] (Mike) wrote:

I read a review on a site where the guy said the picture was horrible and no better than VHS and he said that a tv broadcast of the episodes would look better than the DVD. I would agree with that. He didn't mention any audio problems though.