Live Action South Park

I know some have suggested such a concept for "South Park," so I decided that I might as well give my suggestions for who would play whom were there ever a live action version of the show. Shelly Marsh - Melanie Hutsell (from "SNL") Officer Barbrady - Colin Quinn (also from "SNL") Gerald Broflovski - Gary Oldman Mr. Garrison - Scott Thompson (from "Kids in the Hall") Sorry I couldn't suggest much, since there are a lot of kids in the show. Thanks, Jeremy Gallen a.k.a. J. M. Harrison

I don't think South Park would work as well in live action.

Could the sight of an eight-year-old being killed in a gruesome, gory manner, then being eaten by rats be funny in live action?

I hope South Park always remains animated. Leave well enough alone.