Mecha Streisand VS Damien

S01E12 Mecha-StreisandliveFeb 20, 19982 days later10 posts by 8 posters
10 posts
John M Shuler

I dunno, I'm starting to feel a little out of touch here, folks. I was thoroughly *not* impressed with the whole Damien episode. It was decent, but personally, I thought it was the weakest one so far. Everyone on the newsgroup seemed to have really loved it, though, which wouldn't be that odd if there weren't so many complaints about the Mecha-Streisand episode. Now I'll admit right off the bat that I both (1) Hate Barbara Streisand and (2) Love the old Godzilla movies, but even if those two reasons were not there, I still think that I would have liked the episode. Why? Well, Cartman's "masta got me workin'" song at the beginning, Cartman covering his ass when the kids think that the helicopter is the aliens returning, Mecha-Ike, Kenny's INCREDIBLY funny death (for those who don't get it, it was funny because he died so simply, when you would think he'd get whacked by the monsters), Cartman jumping to get at Kyle's doorknob, the background in the Chef/Leonard car ride, and countless other stuff.

am I really alone? :)

John M. Shuler jshuler at gmu.edu Suppose I go to a PTQ, and play against Justin Schneider (or some other ferret-faced weasel for that matter). -Lionel Thompson

John M Shuler beat on the keyboard and out came:

Yup! You're the only person in Virginia who watches the show!

Naa, I agree with you. Damien was as dull as South Park gets (reads: still a funny show) and Mecha-Ba-Bu-Ra was very funny on many levels (reads:STILL the smartest show on TV)

.________dapete_____in______/\/\ountain__\/iew,___(alifornia________.

Streisand and (2) Love the old Godzilla movies, but even if those two reasons were not there,

I never saw a Godzilla movie, and loved it too.

INCREDIBLY funny death (for those who don't get it, it was funny because he died so simply, when you would think he'd get whacked by the monsters),

It's amazing how people got worked up over this little thing.

I agree completely with you, as I have posted here already....the "Damien" episode had a nice premise but completely lacked humor. This on the other hand, had a shaky premise but pulled it off anyway with superb writing. A dramatic improvement....hope we get more efforts like this week's in the future...

I completely agree with you. I did not really enjoy the Damien episode too much. It could be because I was really psyched for the new episode and might have been expecting too much. And, I thought Mecha Streisand was perhaps THE funniest episode so far. Most of the newsgroup thinks the exact opposite. Maybe it's just me and you on this one dude.

On 20 Feb 1998 06:29:57 GMT, [email] (John M Shuler) offered this unto Shub-Internet:

I'm going off dapete's post here and assuming you got to George Mason here in scenic Northern Virginia. Either I'm wrong about your school or they have lines either in the dorms <which I'm not sure they have> or in a lab somewhere. Am I correct? And how is Mason?

Really? Most of the posts I've read haven't been positive for Damien. While I thought it was good, not many other people seem to share that feeling.

What does one have to do with the other?

Even though I've never really seen a Godzilla movie for more than 10-15 minutes, I still enjoyed this episode. It was no Mr. Hankey, but then again few are. Having not seen Godzilla movies, I'm sure I didn't fully appreciate the related scenes, but they were still good. Shouldn't the characters mouths have not be synched with the lines, though?

You're never alone. We are watching you.

Ia Shub-Internet, Black Goat of a Thousand Servers! Ask not what Thee Shub can do for you, Ask what you can do for Thee Shub. Check out the alt.tv.southpark FAQ:

They have lines in the dorms, and multiple labs. Mason is decent.

Perhaps I'm not reading enough posts. It definitely seemed to me that more people really liked than disliked the Damien episode.

The fact that I consider the second to be much better than the first. Which was odd at the time, but different people find different things funny.

There were quite a few Godzilla references that you wouldn't catch, had you not seen some of the movies, such as the twins in the seashell, and stan's "Robert Smith, do Robot Punch!", for example. Much more funny if you are familiar with the genre, I guess.

John M. Shuler jshuler at gmu.edu Suppose I go to a PTQ, and play against Justin Schneider (or some other ferret-faced weasel for that matter). -Lionel Thompson

John M Shuler wrote:

That's funny. That sorta happened to me. As I watched, I'd see stuff like that line, or Robert Smith freeing the kids, and it'd feel like a 'catch' in my mind, except that I haven't seen any Godzilla movies or the like in ages, the nearest was SpectreMan, and ... Oh dammit, I can't remember its name any more. This kid had a special whistle, that, when he blew it, he could call his robot friends to help him. Blown once, and a human sized robot character in the form of a metallic boy his age came, twice, and a larger Mamma type robot came, three times, and a gigantic Papa robot came. Ah the memories ofd youth. Just can't remember the name of it. But yeah, as soon as I saw that guy shooting lasers out of his eyes, I knew which genre they were 'borrowing' from, and the 'borrowed' bits were pretty easy to spot after, so I had a great laugh. Loved the turtle!

Justin Hiltscher

On 24 Feb 1998 06:51:02 GMT, [email] (John M Shuler) offered this unto Shub-Internet:

Hmmm, sounds good. I didn't think Mason had that, so I hadn't really thought of going there. If it does, though...

Maybe there has been a change of attitude lately, or maybe people just like Damien better than Mecha Streisand. I thought Damien was good the first time I saw it & wasn't real impressed by Mecha Streisand.

Ah, now I understand. Sort of.

I figured the twins must be from a Godzilla-ish movie, and I think I'd heard/seen the robot punch before, probably in some anime. Are the triangles from an acutal movie, or was that made up?

Ia Shub-Internet, Black Goat of a Thousand Servers! Ask not what Thee Shub can do for you, Ask what you can do for Thee Shub. Check out the alt.tv.southpark FAQ: