error in episode in Season 7

Dec 15, 2005, 11:12 PM ET33 posts by 13 postersalt.tv.simpsons
33 posts
Hemdallalt.tv.simpsons

I was watching my Marge head today:

In the episode when Homer goes on disability by reaching 300 pounds, you remember the scene where he's at 299 lbs, so eats a PlayDoh donut to reach 300?

Well, the scale he's standing on only goes up to 300 AFTER he's swallowed the PlayDoh donut. Surely the scale would have gone to 300 the moment he took the PlayDoh donut from Bart's hand! Are we meant to believe this is some sort of magical PlayDoh donut that doesn't have mass or weight until someone swallows it?

I hope somebody got fired for that.

R FlowersHemdallalt.tv.simpsons

"Hemdall" wrote in message news:[email]...

Hmmm... you're right. Well now the rest of the series is just built on a foundation of lies!

--R Flowers --Check out http://groups.google.com/group/alt-politics-simpsons --(It's sooooo boring without you!)
HemdallEverypersonalt.tv.simpsons

"Everyperson" wrote in message news:[email]...

I have a life. I go frame by frame through Simpsons episodes and post sarcastic messages here about errors I find so that strangers can insult me. You?

"Sparky Spartacus" wrote in message news:YdZof.38514$[email]...

Ha ha ha! Stop! Stop! My sides! I only have so many ribs!

Xino KinerHemdallalt.tv.simpsons

me.

You must not have lived very long so far then. I only see five total posts from you so far, AND ONLY ONE of these messages contains a sarcastic message about factual errors. Additionally, only two of the total messages actually contain sarcastic comments. (40%)

Unfortunately for fans such as you and me, many of the regulars at a.t.s. have lost the zeal for discussing factual and continuity errors. Therefore our posts are regarded as "sarcastic" and "anal" and we get picked on and lyrics for songs are written about us.

Then the regulars go on to talk about Australia and Darren Hayes. Then they complain about R** W*** instead of adding him to their killfiles or ignoring him.

Then they mention the curse, and then joke about the Internet being on computers for the millionth time, yet they won't do the "Dental plan! Lisa needs braces!" for the newbies.

Then they make a reference to something that only people 40 or over could POSSIBLY understand, that of course has nothing to do with The Simpsons.

Well it's late and I have to get up early and I can't think of a Simpson's reference to add to make this post on-topic so sorry and good night.

XINO

HemdallXino Kineralt.tv.simpsons

"Xino Kiner" wrote in message news:[email]...

I'm four days old.

Now I'm 3 for 6 (50%).

Little Rascals doesn't start till 6.

Done for you.

Good night.

In alt.tv.simpsons, on the "Re: error in episode in Season 7" thread, Everyperson wrote:

Or at least check the episode capsule to see if the error has been mentioned before. From the "goofs" section in <http://www.snpp.com/episodes/3F05>:

Homer's bathroom scale should register a higher weight as soon as he holds the Play-Doh, but it waits until he eats it. {dd} {dd} = Daniel deHam

Benjamin Robinson [email] This message may or may not contain sarcastic content; your burden to decide "I'm naked, clueless, and f-e-e-e-ling good!" -- Ratbert

You mean to say you haven't read of this?! The Season Set DVDs have been released in Head-shape cases (for Seasons 6 and 7 so far, and are going to be up to Season 10).

Season 6 being a Homer Head, and Season 7 a Marge Head. With the Simpson Kids as the next 3 (though don't know which Season will be which Kid).

Xino KinerJDJF03alt.tv.simpsons

Speaking of the packaging, has anyone gotten the replacement packaging beside Eric and Mr. Garvey? FOX has cashed my parents' check six weeks ago and I'm still waiting.

XINO

1. You will have to wait as long as Bart had to wait for his spy camera. 2. You are giving us hints as to how old you are, etc. Don't do that. You should say something like: "My account with Carte Blance indicates that they have already been paid, but I have yet to receive the aforementioned item."

Aaron Xpac3 Mvx3vm

wrote in message news:[email]...

Xino's 38 and lives in his parents' basement, right?

--R Flowers --Check out http://groups.google.com/group/alt-politics-simpsons --(It's sooooo boring without you!)
R FlowersJohnDalt.tv.simpsons

"JohnD" wrote in message news:rUZof.7647$[email]...

11 - Sarcastic Middle-Aged Guy

I know, weird choice considering whom they have to pick from!

--R Flowers --Check out http://groups.google.com/group/alt-politics-simpsons --(It's sooooo boring without you!)
Xino KinerR Flowersalt.tv.simpsons

Whom the hell do you mean? That bald sarcastic clerk guy who is one of my favorite characters? Lotsa guys could be "Sarcastic Middle-Aged Guy".

Oooooh, what is that smell? Oh, it's you.

XINO

R FlowersXino Kineralt.tv.simpsons

"Xino Kiner" wrote in message news:[email]...

Could be, but there's only one that rates capital letters! But it would appear it should be "Man," not "Guy."

Look here for his appearances : http://www.snpp.com/guides/smam.file.html

and he's mentioned here in the LISA, although not with capital letters: http://www.snpp.com/guides/lisa-3.html#3.2.14

I won't dignifiy this with a reply. Oops, just did.

R Flowers -- Come see alt-politics-simpsons [ http://groups.google.com/group/alt-politics-simpsons ]. -- (It's soooo boring without you)

Hemdall wrote:

No, Homer had a smart scale which didn't include the weight of the donut until it had been digested and it's mass added to Homer's.

As soon as Homer holds the donut in his hand, it is inside his control volume for the purposes of how much he weights. Didn't they teach you any Physics at that Gladiator School?

Aaron Xpac3 Mvx3vm

Didn't you learn at Gladiator School? "Introduction to Fluid Mechanics", by Fox and McDonald, John Wiley and Sons, 1973 edition, Chapter 4. As for the Coriolis Effect, see "Illustrated Experiments in Fluid Mechanics", several authors, MIT Press, 1972 edition, page 63, "Vorticity". BTW, Professor Ascher Shapiro, who made the film about Vorticity and Coriolis Forces in fluids, and was one of my Professors at MIT, passed away recently. He was 88.

Aaron Xpac3 Mvx3vm

"Sparky Spartacus" wrote in message news:187pf.38973$[email]...

Dumbass. In "The Ringer," Johnny Knoxville is playing you.

"Sparky Spartacus" wrote in message news:hPvqf.1389$[email]...

His real name is 'Sammy Chattanooga.'

R Flowers -- Come see alt-politics-simpsons [ http://groups.google.com/group/alt-politics-simpsons ]. -- (It's soooo boring without you)