Frank Grimes!?

Nov 16, 2001, 1:24 AM ET12 posts by 12 postersalt.tv.simpsons
12 posts
SurlyJarrod Balloualt.tv.simpsons

"Homer's Enemy" - 4F19 - Season Eight

But it was a contest for children! Yeah, and Homer beat their brains out!

Highly underrated.

"Surly only looks out for one guy - Surly" "Sorry Surly" "Shut Up"
Andrew HallSurlyalt.tv.simpsons

Surly jibber-jabbed:

Indeed. Grimey is my favorite one shot character because I can see that being my bad day. I can relate and that's always a good thing.

Andy(atuc.com), wants to hear some good quotes!

I like the episode until the end. It's just me, but I never found death funny and it ruins it for me. But everything leading up to it is great. Someone makes observations withing the context of the show that we had noticed from watching it for years!

I disagree. I think the ending sets it apart from other episodes. Granted, it's extremely dark humor, but it's very funny in a twisted sort of way.

I appreciated the direction of the final scene where Homer calls out something in his sleep during the funeral, someone says, "That's our Homer," at which everyone laughs while simultaneously Grimey's coffin is lowered into the grave.

For me it's along the same lines as the scene in Seinfeld when George finds out his fiancee has died. It's extremely dark, but extremely funny.

Brad Filippone wrote:

--- David Ranney Opinions expressed here are not those of IBM

Granted,

I have a fondness for that episode since I attended the table read for it (see http://www.snpp.com/episodes/4F19).

I didn't "get it" while listening to the actors read the script and, after the reading my girlfriend asked "Are they really going to use that ending?" They did. :-)

It wasn't until many months later, when the episode aired, that I realized that Frank Grimes is a real person that has somehow wondered into "Springfield." Maybe they should have drawn him more realistically (five fingers?) or used the story for a THOH episode to make the idea more obvious. In any case, when a joke has to be explained, it probably doesn't work as well.

Of course, thinking of "Grimey" as a real person makes the ending even more ... excuse the pun ... shocking. But that final joke is so like the bad sitcoms it parodies, that I think it works well.

-- Roger Harryfest 2002 - A Celebration of the Music of Harry Nilsson June 14-16, 2002 - Orlando, Florida http://www.harryfest.com/
The RackRoger Smithalt.tv.simpsons

Drunk and full of pie, Roger Smith wrote:

That's exactly what I got out of it. The real world clashes with the satirical world. "If Homer lived in the real world, he'd be dead by now". "He's got you there, Dad." It's the most blatant discussion of Homer (and thus, Americans) done to date on The Simpsons. "You're what's wrong with America, Simpson. You coast through life..." (etc). What made it delicious is that even after all of that information is laid on the table by Grimey, nobody can understand it. They just stare at him. In their world, see, Homer is quite normal.

The episode ends the only way it could; with the man who deserves success killing himself, and lazy Homer breezing over his life lesson with a yawn. Possibly the most sarcastic ending in an episode, ever. I really liked it.

Chadderack : Today's guest is Mr. Roland. He's a painter. Can you say "painter"? : "Rhinoceros"
EDFSurlyalt.tv.simpsons

I'm Lenny. This is Carl and Homer. I'm Lenny.

"Surly" wrote in message news:5X2J7.44663$[email]...

"Hank Scorpio" wrote in message news:[email]...

Oh, a 5-THIRTEEN!!

Workers Of The World Unite, For You Have Nothing To Lose But Your Chains. (Lenin)
Too bad he died.  That was more tragic than funny.
________________________________________________________________

The Indian DVD Resource: http://www.fly.to/indiadvd

What happens when you delete the Recycle Bin?

"Gay" is not a synonym for "bad."

Remove "bination" to reply.