Who (nN) would you cast for the live-action Simpson's Movie?

May 31, 2004, 11:51 PM ET5 posts by 5 posters
5 posts
Hog Huckster

Homer -- John Goodman (Homer is just a mentally challenged Fred Flindstone anyway) -- Second Choice: Ed Harris -- pefect Homer head

Marge -- Shelly Duvall -- She did a great Olive Oyl in the live-action Popeye Second chice: The Dude that plays Robert's wife in Everybody loves Raymond

Bart : Cauley McCulkin -- the perfect Bart -- a kid trapped in a man's body or is it vice versa? (Bart is in his 20's after all). Second Choice -- David Spade (his experience on Dickie Roberts would be a plus).

Lisa -- Any generic Hollywood girl brat will suffice. Let's say, the kid from Uptown Girl.

Maggie -- Use Elizabeth Taylor (she was the original voice of Maggie after all).

Groudskeeper Willie -- Mike Myers (since he loves playing the scotsman) or James Doohan (if he can still walk).

Otto -- Keanu Reeves -- almost a brainless as the Otto character himself. Whoa Dude! I know Kung Fu!

Moe -- Tony Shaloub

Nelson -- That kid from the Public Service announcement on Bullying

Mr. Burns -- Gary Oldman -- good bone structure for the part -- also likes to play crazy old men.

Abe -- Peter Boyle -- good at playing cranky/crazy old men

T.H.H. -- A live action Simpsons could actually work.

;)
Joseph ThompsonHog Huckster

"Hog Huckster" wrote in message news:[email]...

No, it couldn't . . . It would be the spawn of Satan and worse than "Nukie" . . .

Mozilla GuerillaJoseph Thompson

On Tue, 1 Jun 2004 00:12:29 -0500, Joseph Thompson wrote:

Too right! I can't think of one live action movie based on a cartoon show which has worked as well as the original source. A live action Simpsons movie would be a disaster whoever plays the characters, and would almost certainly end up being a blot on 15 years of glorious memories of arguably one of the greatest TV shows in history. Cartoons work because they're cartoons, although I have some doubts as to whether even a feature length cartoon Simpsons would work well. It could, South Park has proved that it can be done, but it would be completely dependent on the script being able to hold things at the expected level for at least 90 minutes rather then the usual 20-25. That will be very difficult to do, but if the Simpsons writers can't do it, I'll be very surprised.

Using M2, Opera's revolutionary e-mail client: http://www.opera.com/m2/

who shot mr burns suffered slightly from length, and that was only 44 minutes, and during the peak time for excellent writing. these days the writers have to come up with three plots, one per act, and string them tenuously together. i don't think they could keep it up for a film.

JQM

Aaron HirshbergHog Huckster

Barney - Bruno Kirby Herman - Joe Buscemi Skinner - Tony Randall. Oops, he's dead, .... THE CURSE, OHMIGOD! Krabapple - The woman who does her voice. Quimby - Bruno Kirby, if he doesn't want to be Barney Smithers - Harry Shearer, John Savage Lenny - Joe Pesci, Ray Liotta Carl - The guy from the Bernie Mac show. I can't remember his name. :-) The guy in Fat Tony's crew who looks like the actor who played Frankie Carbone in that movie about the good fellas, the name of it escapes me at the moment, could be played by that guy!

Space Mvsevm