NY Simpson's Viewer Choice 2004

Oct 7, 2004, 11:15 PM ET27 posts by 11 posters
27 posts
888eight888

It was pretty good last year...

The commercial said log on to nypost.com on October 8th thru (I forget) to vote. (I think last time it was at the fox5ny website.)

There's nothing up on the site yet..so I guess by the time this is posted, voting will be enabled.

Do people in other parts of the country/world get FOX 5 NY via sattelite?...guess you can also vote.

Mr. B888eight888

I'm gonna vote for "The City of New York vs. Homer Simpson" and damnit they better show it!

"Hooters, hooters, yum, yum, yum. Hooters, hooters on a girl that's dumb." - Al Bundy

XPeepleMr. B

Here we go again..

Chris ®XPeeple

Contrary to popular belief, this episode has not been shown on WNYW since before 9/11, despite multiple airings elsewhere. I too urge people to vote for it just to see if they'll actually run it.

Wanted: One .sig. Must be offensive to: - liberals - Yankee fans - the French
XPeepleChris ®

I've seen it on Fox 5 since the attacks, at least once.

Chris ®XPeeple

I've written Fox 5 via e-mail, and they state that the episode has not been played since March 2001.

Wanted: One .sig. Must be offensive to: - liberals - Yankee fans - the French
NothingXPeeple

I haven't seen it on FOX 11 in Southern California since before 9/11. What's the deal?

The Critic is still shown all the time on Comedy Central with it's WTC images and even the Anaheim "World of Disney" store has a WTC painting on one of it's many walls near the ceiling. Painted before 9/11. Fox can't be more PC than Disney.

I love that episode.

XPeepleNothing

A (possibly identical) painting is still in the World of Disney in Orlando, with a Daisy Duck Statue of Liberty in front of the Twin Towers. Just noticed it this summer.

I'm fairly certain that Fox5, the affiliate in the New York City area, aired it about two months after the attacks. Haven't seen it since, though.

I'm not one for PC censorship, but I do think it's probably best to keep this episode under the radar for a while, though a total ban is revisionist. But it makes no sense that "New Kids on the Blecch," which is more offensive by leaps and bounds, isn't similarly "banned." When can we bring it back? Maybe another two years, making five total. God knows we lived through periods without Seinfeld's "The Puerto Rican Day Parade" and "The Contest" in the syndication package for political reasons and the world didn't fall apart.

But as much as the supposed ban is a twinge ludicrous, a movement to show it is just the same. The syndicators ran those episodes into the ground a few years back. Ugh, 2001: Mike Scully was still showrunner, the DVDs hadn't come out yet, and the ONLY episodes shown in syndication were seasons 9-11 (ironically enough). It was a dark time for Simpsons fans. I could probably recite "Marge Simpson in: 'Screaming Yellow Honkers'" verbatim if I needed to, considering it ran at least twice a month for about two years, and I may shoot my TV if I ever have to sit through "Maximum Homerdrive" again. I could really go without seeing any episode crediting "Executive Producer Mike Scully" for a decade or so, thanks.

4F22 is as sub-standard as anything produced in that era, IMO; about as "real" a portrayal of New York City as any given episode of Friends. I think the only thing noteworthy about it was the first appearance of Duffman. Ian Maxtone Graham's track record is probably as checkered as Scully's..

Chris ®XPeeple

You're wrong. I e-mailed them about this very subject and they stated that they haven't aired it since March of 2001.

Wanted: One .sig. Must be offensive to: - liberals - Yankee fans - the French
XPeepleChris ®

Firstly, it's unlikely that this scenario is realistic. Fox 5, among other affiliates, were only airing seasons 9-11 at the time. That's maybe 65 episodes, three times a day (IIRC). March through September is, what, ~20 weekdays a month, 3 times a day, for 6 months? 360 airings, not even including the weekend syndication schedule. It would be statistically near impossible for the episode not to have aired at *least* once during that time.

Secondly, "Fox 5" saying that the episode hasn't aired means bobkes. The people at a company who are assigned e-mails? Low-level interns who've been at the company less than a year, usually. I've been one of them. I'm not going to put any more faith into an answer from the e-mail staff at Fox 5 than I do the incompetent e-mail staff from any other company.

Chris ®XPeeple

I often find it amusing to see what lengths people will go to to avoid saying that they were wrong.

Wanted: One .sig. Must be offensive to: - liberals - Yankee fans - the French
XPeepleChris ®

I'm not the only person who's seen it on Fox 5 since the attacks:

http://groups.google.com/groups?hl=en&lr=&selm=20030821083345.21828.000007 97%40mb-m07.aol.com

http://groups.google.com/groups?hl=en&lr=&selm=20030602203513.27337.000006 62%40mb-m03.aol.com

http://groups.google.com/groups?hl=en&lr=&selm=cdc28d5f.0205101153.dc2af58 %40posting.google.com
Chris ®XPeeple

You're not the only person who has mistakenly though he/she has seen it (or passed off some bullshit) on Fox 5.

I repeat again: Fox 5 has not shown this episode since March of 2001. This is what they say, not me.

Wanted: One .sig. Must be offensive to: - liberals - Yankee fans - the French
XPeepleChris ®

I often find it amusing to see what lengths people will go to to avoid saying that they were wrong.

888eight888XPeeple

[email] (XPeeple) wrote in message news:...

Let's just say that people, (i.e. New Yorkers), can't handle seeing a cartoon image of the WTC. (I am not really sure I understand this - but, whatever.) In the NY Simpsons episode, Homer is waiting outside of the WTC while that device is locked on to his car's wheel, right? How about they remove all of the full shots of the WTC from the episode. How many seconds could that possibly be? Let's say that, while Homer is at ground level, somehow viewers are still "traumatized" by recognizing that the building in the background is the WTC - change the background to something else. When he runs upstairs in the building, add a shot of a different building to make it look like he is running up the stairs of a different building. The content of the story will basically remain the same. If, after all those edits/add-ins...that the ep would still be considered an "insensitive" episode -that would just be ridiculous. New York City is the subject/backdrop for a countless number of movies, tv shows, plays and novels.

If they added/took out parts -they could run that version in syndication and for the purists, they could eventually offer the uncut version of the episode on DVD -for people that can "handle it".

XPeeple888eight888

That's a stupid idea and Gracie Films certainly isn't going to spend money re-animating or re-recording lines on something they did nine years ago. They're not George Lucas, you know.

888eight888XPeeple

[email] (XPeeple) wrote in message news:...

Sorry you think it's a stupid idea - but if you added up the total amount seconds that the WTC appears, it couldn't be much...It wouldn't take George Lucas to re-draw a background in a tv cartoon. It could be put back in syndication and make money again - for the low, low intoductory price of pasting in a couple of backgrounds in a friggin' cartoon. (;

Darren888eight888

888eight888 wrote:

The BBC here in England also had a problem showing the episode in New York (when they had the rights that is), they would schedule it, then change it for Bart Gets an F at the last moment.

Quite what the problem is, Channel 4 broadcasts loads of Friends episodes per day, most with the WTC in the background, and I doubt many people even notice.

I know that England isnt New York, but surely no one can be offended by a cartoon image of some buildings? And just out of interest, are Friends (Unedited) Series 1-7 still shown in America?

Darren
888eight888Darren

Darren wrote in message news:...

First off, on behalf of all Americans, let me offer my deepest, heartfelt sympathy to you, your family, your friends and your country. I am so very, very sorry that you are subjected to "loads of Friends episodes per day".

Not only has each and every American seen every episode of Friends, we also know every excruciating detail of the personal lives of all the actors from Friends, (it's a requirement for citizenship).

So, yeh..they show Seasons 1 thru 7 here.

Darren888eight888

888eight888 wrote:

You probably dont believe me when i say loads of episodes, but Channel 4 run 2 Channels, C4 and E4.

And on a typical day C4 shows Friends at 07:25 then another at 18:00, and on a Friday, extra 1 at 20:30 E4 17:00, 17:30, 20:00 and 20:30, weekends you can more episodes per channel.

I'm not sure how mad America went on the day of "The Last One" but Channel 4 did about 12:30pm to 21:30 with back to back Episodes, with only a few hours break for the news, Richard and Judy (Chat show, that day about Friends) and Gameshow Countdown.

The Simpsons starts on Channel 4 in a few weeks, (they got the rights from BBC) and will probably show every episode so many times the tape will burn out.

Darren
888eight888Darren

Darren wrote in message news:...

Godspeed, my friend...Godspeed.

Mark Wilson888eight888

"888eight888" wrote in message news:[email]...

news:...

Why should they though?!!

Honestly. Some people are farrrr to sensitive. Quick! Change everything that the WTC appears in! It might offend somebody! Let's pretend the buildings were never there.

What happened was a tragedy, but changing an old episode of a tv show because it shows the Twin Towers? Come off it. What about shows like "Mad About You", "Sex And The City" and "Friends" which feature backdrops of the city in cut scenes. You can still see the Twin Towers here. Should THESE also be changed? I think these should be LEFT ALONE, as memories of when the world was a more peaceful place.

What's done is done and y'all need to GET OVER IT.

Matt GarveyXPeeple

XPeeple wrote:

And then what if they decided to honor the memory of all who have been victims of the Curse?

Jsonitsac888eight888

[email] (888eight888) wrote in message news:...

That sort of poll isn't unusual. I know the Fox affiliate down here in Washington did a similar poll, but since Murdoch doesn't control a newspaper (our "conservative alternative" here is run by a cult) in DC, you had to vote on their webpage.

888eight888888eight888

The voting is now enabled at:

http://nypost.com/contests/SIV2004a.htm =============================================================== Tell us your top five all-time favorite Simpsons episodes. Then Fox 5 will air the top 20 reader episodes every weekday at 6:30 and 7:00 from November 8 - 19. Everyone who votes will be entered into a random drawing to win these super Simpsons prizes: ONE HUNDRED (100) FIRST PRIZE WINNERS WILL EACH RECEIVE: The Simpsons TM: The Complete Fourth Season Collector's Edition DVD

ONE HUNDRED (100) RUNNERS UP WILL EACH RECEIVE: The Bart Book or The Homer Book, from the all new Simpsons Library of Wisdom Series

Some of your Favorite Simpsons episodes from seasons 1-15:

Life on the Fast Lane Marge contemplates having an affair with a local womanizer after Homer selfishly buys her a bowling ball for her birthday

Homer's Night Out Bart photographs Homer with belly-dancer Princess Kashmir

The Crepes of Wrath To Homer's delight, Bart is sent to France for the summer as part of a student exchange program

Krusty Gets Busted When Homer positively identifies Krusty the Clown as an armed robber, Bart attempts to clear his idol's name

Bart Gets An F Bart must pass a critical history test or he will be held back a grade

Simpson & Delilah Homer's life changes dramatically when he purchases a miracle hair growth formula

Two Cars In Every Garage And Three Eyes On Every Fish Homer supports Mr. Burns in his bid for governor, but Marge remains loyal to Burns' political opposition

The Way He Was Marge recounts to her children how she and Homer first met and fell in love

Saturdays Of Thunder Realizing he has not been a good father to Bart, Homer aids his son in building a soap box racer

Flaming Moe's Homer gives Moe the recipe for a unique alcoholic drink, and when it turns into a sensation, Moe takes credit, and the profits - from its success

Homer Alone When Marge reaches the breaking point, she leaves for a much needed vacation, leaving the rest of the family to realize how much she does for them

Homer At The Bat Mr. Burns bets one million dollars that his power plant's softball team will win the championship

Lisa's First Word Marge recounts how Lisa first spoke as the family awaits baby Maggie's first word

Brother From The Same Planet Bart tires of Homer's lack of interest in him and chooses another father from the Big Brother program

I Love Lisa Lisa feels the pity for Ralph, a nerdy classmate, and gives him a card on Valentine's Day

Marge On The Lam Marge joins divorcee Ruth Powers for a wild night on the town, only to discover that her friend is driving a stolen vehicle

Boy-Scoutz N The Hood Bart inadvertently joins the Junior Campers, and during a rafting trip, he becomes lost at sea with Homer and Ned Flanders

Homer And Apu Apu offers the Simpsons his services as valet after he is fired from the Kwik-E-Mart for selling rancid meat

Homer The Great Homer's popularity skyrockets when he is chosen as the leader of a secret organization

Lisa On Ice Lisa joins a hockey team and finds herself pitted against Bart in a critical game

Bart's Comet Bart discovers a comet that is on a collision course with Springfield

Homer Vs. Patty & Selma Homer is forced to borrow money from Patty & Selma after he wipes out the family's savings by investing in pumpkins

Who Shot Mr. Burns? (Part One) Just about everyone in Springfield vows to kill Mr. Burns after he cheats the elementary school out of a newly discovered oil well - and threatens to block out the sun

Who Shot Mr. Burns (Part Two) Lisa aids the police with the investigation of the Burns shooting

King-Size Homer Homer intentionally gains weight so he can qualify for disability and work at home

Mother Simpson After Homer fakes his own death, his long-thought-deceased mother arrives in Springfield to pay her last respects

You Only Move Twice The Simpsons relocate to another community after Homer unwittingly takes a job with a company controlled by a super-villian

The Homer They Fall Homer becomes a professional boxer when doctors discover he was born with a unique genetic condition that protects his brain from injury

Burns, Baby Burns With Homer's help, Mr. Burns' long-lost son stages his own kidnapping

Bart Carny A carnival worker and his son move in with the Simpsons after Homer costs them their jobs

The Two Mrs. Nahasapeemapetilons In an effort to annul an arranged marriage, Apu tells his mother he wed Marge

Viva Ned Flanders Homer shows Flanders how to enjoy life by taking him to Las Vegas

Maximum Homerdrive Homer and Bart attempt to deliver a dead trucker's cargo on schedule. Meanwhile, Marge decides to have an adventure of her own�and purchase a new doorbell

Mom And Pop Art Homer pursues a career as an artist when his barbecue pit attracts the attention of a gallery T he Mansion Family The Simpsons care for Burns' mansion when the billionaire leaves town for a medical exam

Alone Again, Natura-Diddly Homer attempts to help when Flanders experiences a tragic loss

Missionary Impossible Homer is forced to become a missionary on a remote island after he pledges a large sum of money to PBS

Homr Homer experiences a dramatic increase in intelligence when researchers remove a crayon lodged in his brain

Large Marge Marge's life changes dramatically when her attempt to lose weight via surgery results in larger breasts; inspired by the classic Batman TV show, Bart and Millhouse get into mischief that leads to a public relations nightmare for Krusty

Worst Episode Ever When the Comic Book Guy suffers a heart attack, Bart and Millhouse take over his store

James Allen888eight888

What a lame list of choices. Any selection list without "Last Exit to Springfield," "22 Short Films About Springfield" and "Krusty Gets Cancelled" is a pretty substandard list.

Key-BoredJames Allen

"James Allen" wrote in message news:[email]...

But is it worthy of the "Worst List Ever" honor?