Question forom previous Seinfeld

S03E19 The LimoretroMay 30, 1993, 10:35 AM ET15 months later6 posts by 6 posters
Question

Fans discuss a joke from "The Limo" where George hums "If I Were a Rich Man" from Fiddler on the Roof in a limo with Nazis, explaining the song's significance as a Jewish cultural reference.

6 posts
Geoffrey R Golub

I have a question about a previous Seinfeld episode.

It is about a joke that I guess I still don't understand.

It is from the episode from the 91-92 season, when George goes to pick Jerry up at the airport, and his car breaks down, and the decide to take "O'Brian" 's limo. Well, O'Brian turns out to be the leader of the Aryan Union (or something like that). For those who have seen this episode you may remember at one point wher J. and G. are in the limo with Eva and that guy (can't remember his name), and George starts humming some song and Jerry smacks him to get him to stop singing this song. It must be some t

ype of anti-nazi or pro-jewish song, because Jerry did not want these two nazis that he was riding with to hear this song.

My question is this: what is the name of the song, and what is its significance?

Jeffrey H KahnGeoffrey R Golub

The song that George was humming in "The Limo" was "If I Were a Rich Man", from "Fiddler on the Roof". The play is about the plight of a Jewish family in early 1900's Russia. Definitely not the tune someone like O'Brian would have been humming although we can't put it past George!

Jef.

David SteinmanJeffrey H Kahn

[email] (Jeffrey H Kahn) writes:

That's the point. Imagine humming a song about Russian Jews in a limo full of Nazis. Also, I believe Jason Alexander did "Fiddler" on stage at some point, so this reference is even more "profound".

Dave!
Tom MahaffeyJeffrey H Kahn

Did anyone else see this song in the movie Hollywood Knights? This movie was a great one indeed, costarring a very young Michelle Pfeifer and Tony Danza (a few more people too). The guy who was siging "IIWARM" played a geek in this movie, but the actor eventually went on to star in "Not Necessarily the News" and some other stuff. Also, another actor in HK had a bit part in the Madonna video for "Material Girl" (she's the biggest star in the world...etc.).

Tom

Tim IngramTom Mahaffey

The actor you're referring to is Stuart Pankin (I think), from NNTN. He played the geeky honor student with the violin in HK.

-tim

[email] is Tim Ingram
HORN, D KTom Mahaffey

In article [email] (Tom Mahaffey) writes:

Well, The Hollywood Knights is a great movie--truly great, and more people should check it out. The guy who played Dudley ("the geek," although I'd describe him as more of a nebbish) was Stuart Painkin, who *did* go on to do "Not Necessarily The News." The "other actor," was Robert Wuhl, who portrayed my favorite, Newbomb Turk. He also played the Vicki Vale's erstwhile reporting partner in the first BATMAN movie. I remember him on Late Night talking about how he was going to get a cut of the action figures sold from the movie...but only for *his* character: "Yeah, every kid's gonna want the 'Reporter'" doll... " Anyway, I haven't said much about Seinfeld, have I? It's my favorite sitcom on TV, all right, now that Northern Exposure has unfortunately become too self- conscious. My favorite episode, like most people's, is "The Contest," which has to be one of the most bugged-out broadcasts ever, right up there with "Fall Out." I'm surprised, reading the poll, that Kramer is so far ahead of George in popularity...I mean, I expected him to be ahead, but only about 9% for George? Also, I wonder if the recently reported rise in cigar sales (for the first time since 1964) is due to Kramer...

                                                   Peace out,
                                                   Carl Horn

"Snapple?"