Tonights episode (06/09/97)?

S09E17 The BookstoreliveApr 9, 1998the same night24 posts by 19 posters
😡 Hated it🔥 Controversial

Fans overwhelmingly dislike this episode, calling it one of the worst with poor pacing, dead air, and disjointed storylines that feel thrown together.

24 posts
Niraj Agarwalla

Tonights episode absolutely sucks. The show was not funny at all. It seems there was a lot of dead air tonite.

Niraj Agarwalla -- [email] -- http://www.shore.net/~niraj

I totally agree. When I read the discription on the net it sounded cool but when I saw it I thought "this has got to be the worst episode of Seinfeld ever!" The ONLY funny part of the episode was the begining teaser w/ Kramer. I wonder who wroote that episode. Anyone know? I'd like to hear other fan's feedback about this episode.

Niraj Agarwalla wrote:

> Tonights episode absolutely sucks. The show was not funny at all. It > seems there was a lot of dead air tonite. > > --

In article ,

Two funny things I liked was when one of the homeless guys said "The government". The other was one of the homeless guys was named Rusty, the same as the farting horse.

The plots though are just as outlandish as the original series that Seinfeld is based on--Gilligan's Island.

Later,

Zuke

You are in control until you are out of control. [email]

As usual I am in the minority, as I really liked last night's episode. True it wasn't the funniest show ever but I found it very enjoyable. Good to see Newman and Uncle Leo back in the picture.

I've said this before and I'll say it agian.  STOP WATCHING SEINFELD.   You
people who bitch about EVERY show will NEVER BE HAPPY.   I liked tonights
episode.  No wait.... I LOVED IT.  Do us all a big favor and switch  over and
watch that 3 guys and a pizza place  and then say the Seinfeld sucks.

The episode that was on tonight was great. For those who refuse to like Sein anymore may I suggest Diagnosis Murder.

I thought it was pretty good too. Not as great the past five episodes (The Reverse Peephole, The Cartoon, The Strongbox, The Wizard, and The Burning), but it still had a lot of laughs in it.

Swarm! Swarm!

Dave "Loopy" Nusair        			  [email]
,.,.,.,.,.,.,.,.,.,.,.,.,.,.,.,.,.,.,.,.,.,.,.,.,.,.,.,.,.,.,.,.,.,.,.,.,.
; "Rosebud...  Yes, Rosebud Frozen Peas.  Full of country goodness and   ;

; the road. Mmm. Oh, what luck! There's a french fry stuck in my ;

;.,.,.,.,.,.,.,.,.,.,.,.,.,.,.,.,.,.,.,.,.,.,.,.,.,.,.,.,.,.,.,.,.,.,.,.,;
Dept. of Good Vibes,                  Come visit my Reel Film Reviews site
Carleton University                  at "http://chat.carleton.ca/~dnusair"

On 10 Apr 1998 03:12:59 GMT, [email] (David Nusair) wrote:

No, I'd have to agree with the aformentioned. This episode was definatley one of the worst ever. It ties witht the second part of the one were jerry had his car stolen. I mean it had no flow whatsoever and the it seemed thrown together. Like they took 3 differnent scripts and tried to fuse them. The part about Elaine taking care of the heroin addict was absolutley terrible. If you think this Seinfeld was any good, you obviously haven't been watching it very long. Compare this season to 3 seasons ago and you'll see. Hopefully the finale can make up for it.

When are people going to get out of the past. Three seasons ago is just that -3 seasons ago, or 5 seasons ago. Here is something that may help you out. The first time you see or experience something as original as Seinfeld it will never seem as funny again. There may be exceptions, but in general the show will never be as refreshing as it once was. That does not mean the show is bad. The show is competing against itself and that is unfair. Some of the crazy, unpredictable things the show did back then would still not be as funny today. You know, I was a little pissed at first that Jerry took his show of the air when it had at least one more good year left.(compared to what is on TV today) However, after reading some of the comments from so called "classic Seinfeld fans", I agree with Jerry that he should just shut down the show. What sucks is that the people who are going to get screwed are the people that really just love that show. That's a bummer! P.S.-- "The bookstore" was a hilarious episode!!!!! Oh, I forgot it is 1998 not 1994 I guess then it sucked. "It is very unhealthy to expend all ones energy and time for a television show.... Join a gym!"

paranoid android <no_paranoia> wrote in article ...

This episode may actually have sucked badly. Does anybody know what episode of Seinfeld was on June 9, 1997

Zaphymcfly

On 10 Apr 1998 14:30:58 GMT, "mcfly" regurgitated:

ah yes the "I like your old stuff better than your new stuff" syndrome. Why do fans of TV shows, bands etc always tend to do this?

[email] (Zaphy) penned the following words:

Two reasons:

1) People hate change. 2) New material that's the same as old material looks worse in comparison.

Sort of a Catch-22, ain't it?

As far as I can tell, the only way to avoid this is to put out one or two brilliant (TV seasons, movies, albums, novels) and kill yourself in a bizzare farming accident.

Joshua Hall Bachner [email] The Authoritative M:tG reference: http://www.frontiernet.com/~phopkins/?ch

On 10 Apr 1998 14:30:58 GMT, "mcfly" wrote:

Well, then explain what was funny about it? I was watching and thinking, Jesus Christ, I'm glad he's throwing in the towel. Its sickening watching something so great die a slow and horrible death. "The Bookstore" was absolutley terrible. And since you insist on it. Newsradio, Alley McBeel, Frasier, and Friends are all better television shows at the moment. I can't say I would choose them over Seinfeld, but as of this season they are much better. Jerry has lost it. Without Larry David he has no idea what a good script is. I was so glad to see Larry come back for the final episode. Alas, some classic Seinfeld. Seinfeld is a great comedian, and over the course of 8 seasons he has become a good actor. But as far as writing producing and directing go, he has no clue. But thats just my opinion, i could be wrong??? >:o)

In case you haven't noticed, they aren't dying a slow and horrible death. They're dying "on top of the world". Every critic who bashed Seinfeld early this season has practically taken back what they said, saying that the show is back to its best. Its not a very good time to be a critic of Seinfeld, especially with the final episode just around the corner.

I'll agree about Newsradio and Ally, because they are some of the best shows right now. Frasier has had its moments, and Friends is still relying on Ross and Rachel to drive their show.

I can't say I would choose them over<BR>

He doesn't write, there are about 15-20 Seinfeld writers (he only writes with Larry David and Larry Charles), he actually is a very good producer, and he doesn't direct, Andy Ackerman does (before that Tom Cherones, and Jason Alexander directed one episode).

Jeez, I wonder what you will do after the last Seinfeld airs, I guess you can join the other newsgroups and complain about them. It's kind of frustrating to watch a great TV series only to come to this newsgroup and see people post nonsense. I liken it to people saying that Michael Jordan should retire, because he not the classic Jordan, i.e. he shoots more jumpshots. IMO, Seinfeld has not lost anything that is noticeable. Shows like Friends, Frazier, and Newsradio could only wish to one day have the impact that Seinfeld does. If those shows are so entertaining, at least more so than Jerry, why don't you spend your time in those newsgroups and come back here to complain after the last episode. I know you won't, none of the anti-Seinfeld posters ever do, instead you guys live each day anticipating Thursday's episode so you can complain about it. Talk about how sad Seinfeld has become, IMO it's sadder that you feel that way and still watch the show. Maybe when the bookstore airs as a re-run, then you will probably enjoy it.

no_paranoia (paranoid android) wrote in message ...

Seinfeld

the

he

going

just wanted to change the name of the thread, got annoying talking about an episode in JUNE rather than April

Scott J. Friedman [email] ** MAY 14TH - FINAL SEINFELD EPISODE ** no_paranoia (paranoid android) wrote in message

On Fri, 10 Apr 1998 10:20:35 -0400, Scott J. Friedman wrote:

Just wondering why you didn't correct the *year* as well, while you were at it... <BG>

Jeff Shirton                                                  [email]
=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=
  "He didn't sound like a baseball player.  He said things like
  'Nevertheless', and 'if, in fact.' " -- Dan Quisenberry on Ted Simmons
__

In article , no_paranoia (paranoid android) writes:

Yeah, I know what you mean. When I first started smoking crack 3 years ago, I thought it was the greatest thing since Seinfeld. I've been trying to get back that same feeling ever since, but it's just not as good...

Mitchell Virchick wrote:

Tell me about it.....

Niraj Agarwalla -- [email] -- http://www.shore.net/~niraj

Well, I'm glad I'm not the only one who enjoyed last night's episode. It was a bit different, but I thought it was really good. Maybe I'm just a big Uncle Leo fan. :-)

Niraj Agarwalla wrote:

You have got to be joking. No one can be that humorless. Oh, well...

maro

Okay, okay. I did like the opening sequence. But for the rest, oh well...

Niraj Agarwalla -- [email] -- http://www.shore.net/~niraj

That's because you forgot to turn on your TV. Jeez you must be dumb to stare at a blank screen for half an hour. For those of us who figured out how to use our TV sets, tonight's episode was a blast.

Niraj Agarwalla wrote in article ...