Elaine's Cigar

S07E20 The CalzoneliveApr 26, 1996the next day12 posts by 8 posters
😂 Loved it🔥 Controversial

Fans discuss their attraction to Elaine smoking a cigar in the episode, with mixed reactions about whether it looks sexy or vulgar, and analysis of the psychological appeal.

12 posts
WT Pfefferle, Ph.D.

I've never seen anything more sexy, more seductive, or more exciting than Elaine and that damn cigar in The Calzone. It drives me crazy. Someone must post a GIF of the damn thing so I can have it on my computer forever. Please, Lanie...you're killing us out here!

[email] co-author of PLUG IN--The Guide to Music on the Net available from Prentice Hall nationwide http://www.prenhall.com/~plugin

You're kidding, right? I mean, this is some sort of joke, right?

What is so sexy about women smoking cigars? It does not make them look attractive at all. Women smoking cigars always makes me feel a little queasy.

If Elaine is trying to look chic or trendy, she should lay off the cigars, they make her look vulgar. I know this is a new trend in Hollywood, but, to me, it does not make women look attractive at all.

Kyle

I suspect that those men who find it attractive are seduced by the quasi-phallic "subliminal" image it represents. This is pretty ham-handed psychology, but these guys see a woman lovingly caress a tubular object with their mouth..... It may not be conscious, but there ya go.

RFerrie wrote:

In support of Dr. Pfefferle (the original poster) I, too, found that to be a rather provocative scene. And I don't disagree entirely with Mr Ferrie's analysis of the phenomenon. I do think, however, that being a smoker or a non-smoker may influence your perception. As an occasional cigar smoker, I'm always pleased to meet/see others who also enjoy cigars, especially women.

OTOH, people who don't give a second thought to a man smoking a cigar but who find women who smoke cigars vulgar, are trapped by traditional gender stereotypes.

One other point: This 'trend' is not limited to Hollywood. On the local news a few weeks back they featured a women's cigar smoking club that meets monthly at a local coffee house. They said that between 20 and 30 women attend the meetings regularly. From what I could see, most of them looked to be well dressed business women. This also reminds me of that Tostitoes comercial where the women are sitting around playing poker, drinking beer, smoking cigars, and stuffing there face with chips. I love that comercial.

Finally:

Sometimes a cigar is just a cigar.

Monty "Demonstrating once again that subtle difference between creativity and complex stupidity" -- Dogbert

[email] (Monty D. Martin) wrote:

Mr. Martin strikes me as being a very reasonable and wonderful person -- mostly because he came to my defense. The earlier post that talked about the phallic nature of Elaine's cigar was on the point as well. Adding to the problem that if I saw Elaine sniffing a sock I would likely find something of the erotic in that.

So, to sum up. A cigar may be just a cigar, but Lanie, now she's a smoke.

Best.

[email] (W.T. Pfefferle, Ph.D.) wrote:

Thanks, Doc. I laughed so hard I cried. Then I started thinking about Elaine sniffing a sock (Jessica Hecht's sock). To make a short story even shorter, I am no longer the 'Prince of the Palace'.

Oh good, a new sig quote. Hope you don't mind.

Monty

"A cigar may be just a cigar, but Lanie, now she's a smoke." -- W.T. 'Doc' Pfefferle, PhD.

In Mike Vandenberg writes:

When you enjoy a cigar thats the way you smoke it. Beyond that most activities in this series employ exaggerated movements. Elaine shoves people, Kramer whirls around and falls down. An ecstatic puffing on a cigar does not have to have Freudian significance. RD

In Mike Vandenberg writes:

shoves

a

We all see it our own way..that's a given. Most everything posted is a subjective opinion. That should be obvious. Saying "you see it your way, I see it my way" adds nothing to the discussion. What is "your way"?