Did Elaine Write "The Rogue's Wallet?"

S04E05 The Wallet (1)retroJun 28, 19964 years later5 posts by 5 posters
🧠 Theory🔥 Controversial
5 posts
Mike

In Lee Salem writes:

no beacuse george didn't kill her mother. j peterman wrote it because he thought george killed his mother.

Calling

character

bu he doesn't use george's name. george could never proove it was about him without showing that he might have killed peterman's mother.

mike

Lee SalemMike

Of course the copy for "The Rogue's Wallet" mentions George's name! Right before the line, "He killed my mother," is a line which says, "His name was Costanza." Last time I looked, George's last name was Costanza!

Also, just because George did not kill ELAINE'S mother doesn't mean she can't write the copy for the wallet. Creative writers can write about ANYTHING! Novelists, playwrights and screenwriters (even "Seinfeld" writers) write about things that are not in their experiences in the first person when necessary. Peterman could have TOLD Elaine his concept and she could have come up with the copy. Peterman is "The Big Cheese." "Big Cheeses" usually hire other people (like Elaine) to do the day-to-day work while they run the higher levels of the business. Why would Peterman hire Elaine to write copy if he was writing copy himself? He could simply save the money.

Michael Josefson

If memory serves, Elaine read "The Rogues Wallet" with some surprise and astonsihment that it got into the catalogue. Unless that was an act she put on so George wouldn't know it was her who wrote the copy, that would tend to suggest to me that she didn't write the copy, but Peterman did...

Zachary M. Garcia

In Lee Salem writes:

the

His

Calling

character

A couple of things. . .

Elaine didn't write that copy. Peterman had to have. He probably would have the final say so on everything. Also George would never be able to figure out that he could sue Peterman. He's not that smart.

Zach