Kramer's book

S08E10 The Andrea DoriaretroFeb 23, 2002, 8:51 PM ET5 years later5 posts by 5 posters
Question

Fans discuss whether Kramer wrote or simply owned the book 'Astonishing Tales of the Sea' featured in the Andrea Doria episode, with debate over the phrasing of his claim.

5 posts
Vicki Jones

Does anyone know if Kramer wrote the book "Astonishing Tales of the Sea" in the Andrea Doria episode?

MichealVicki Jones

no, he didnt write it, he just owned it

Vicki Jones wrote:

osmiumVicki Jones

Vicki Jones writes:

in

I am in the small minority who believe he wrote it. IIRC he said, "It's in my book ....". To me, it makes no sense for a native speaker of English to say that in reference to a book he simply *owns*. Does this imply he only possesses one book? No dictionary? How can one live without a dictionary?

Art Vandelayosmium

<<<<....... To me, it makes no sense for a native speaker of English to say that in reference to a book he simply *owns*. Does this imply he only possesses one book? No dictionary? How can one live without a dictionary?>>>>

He borrows Jerry's.

^^^^^^ "Art is often hailed as the grandest expression of human spirit, but we know now ... that the grandest expression of human spirit is whatever it takes for a man or woman to rush back into a burning building to save more people."

unknownosmium

On Sun, 24 Feb 2002 14:39:53 GMT, "osmium" wrote:

In real life I agree with you but they are putting on a play and the lines are written for them. I think Michael Richards just delivered that line in an comedic efficient way. If he says "It's in a book I own called "Astonishing Tales of the Sea". it is a bit too wordy and awkward. When he refers to the "Astound Bear Attacks" It is clearly one he owns, not wrote.

I'll stick with the majority.  :-)
=======================================================

KRAMER: it's in my book - "Astonishing Tales of the Sea" 51 people died.

GEORGE: 51 people?!

KRAMER: That's it?! I thought it was, like, a thousand!

KRAMER: There were 1,650 survivors.

GEORGE: That's no tragedy! How many people do you lose on a normal cruse? 30? 40?! Kramer, can I take a look at that book? (Starts walking tward the door.

Kramer grabs his food, and follows)

KRAMER: Oh yeah. I also got "Astounding Bear Attacks"

The News Guy(Mike) - Seinfeld Lists http://www.geocities.com/tnguym All things Seinfeld; scripts, trivia, lists,