Bill O'Reilly almost quotes George Costanza

Aug 3, 2004, 1:04 PM ET8 posts by 6 postersalt.tv.seinfeld
🧩 Trivia🙂 Liked it

Thread discusses Bill O'Reilly's statement about believing something makes it not a lie, noting similarity to George Costanza's quote from the show.

8 posts
steve horanalt.tv.seinfeld

It's funny, when Bill O'Reilly was debating Michael Moore he almost quoted George Costanza's "It's not a lie if you believe it." That's what George said, right?

Here's what O'Reilly said in defense of Bush's deceptions:

O'REILLY: "Just the issues. You've got three separate investigations plus the president of Russia all saying� British intelligence, U.S. intelligence, Russian intelligence, told the president there were weapons of mass destruction, you say, "he lied." This is not a lie if you believe it to be true, now he may have made a mistake, which is obvious �"

:-)
osmiumsteve horanalt.tv.seinfeld

steve horan writes:

That's a good example of why a transcript is a bad way to figure out what happened during an interchange. It's all in inflection, I don't know the proper words but my stab at would be that George said it "archly". I am quite sure O'Reilly did not say it that way. The inflection totally changes the meaning.

I was trekfan666 writes:

I don't know who "you people" is. I, unlike both John Kerry and John Edwards, have been opposed to the invasion of Iraq since day 1. I was simply making the observation that a written transcript is a very poor way of following events.

But then, some people can not be communicated with in any known fashion :-(

Jeez!

JedIncubusalt.tv.seinfeld

You're a raging anti-dentite!!

"Incubus" wrote in message news:cetsk5$5rb$[email]... > Next you'll be saying they should have their own schools. >
steve horanosmiumalt.tv.seinfeld

"osmium" wrote in message news:...

George paused before he said it and then he spoke very deliberately as though he were imparting great words of wisdom. If that's what you mean by "archly", then yes :-)

George was suggesting that Jerry, in order to fool the "poly", needs to lie to himself convincly enough that he believes his own BS. O'Reilly is spinning, he's already gone through that transformation :-) When Bush said that he, Bush, was sure... well, he's not accountable because he was misinformed even though he, George W Bush, was sure there were WMD's. He should've had George Tenet deliver the State of the Union address as then there'd be no vague whiff of responsibility for his words.