WHY I HATE GEORGE?

S05E16 The Stand-InliveFeb 25, 1994, 2:51 PM ETthe next day19 posts by 17 posters
😡 Hated it🔥 Controversial

Viewers debate George's character, with some finding his anal-retentive personality annoying while others appreciate his pathetic humor.

19 posts
agarwalln

I HATE GEORGE CASTANZA, HE IS ANAL-RETENTIVE LITTLE TWERP.

RASPUTIN

ThwartedEffortsagarwalln

In article [email] writes:

no, you have it all wrong, it's Jerry who's anal retentive

Lyndaagarwalln

In article [email] writes:

That's why I LOVE him . . . he' so pathetic !

Eric B Gemunderagarwalln

In article , wrote:

Please stop shouting. You are giving me a headache. BTW, the caps lock key is on the left of the keyboard, if you're looking to turn it off.

Eric Gemunder | "I gotta go where there ain't any snow... [email] | I gotta go where it's warm!"- J. Buffett
Jan Penovichagarwalln

In article , [email] writes:

So, what's your point?

  j.
amdagarwalln

Home improvement is a lot better than Seinfeld. alot funnier.

Christina Margellosamd

[email] wrote:

I sense a flame...should I be immature and respond to this?

I can't resist.

Why would you bother to put a comment like this in this particular newsgroup? Are you a glutton for punishment???

Your NameChristina Margellos

Obviously, someone posts something like this in this particular news group to get people in an uproar and start a flame war.

The real question is why can't you recognize the original posting for what it is ? You have been baited.

David Gregory Plattamd

In [email] writes:

Why do you even bother posting? This isn't even worth flaming, but here goes anyway...

Home Improvement is a pathetic, pathetic show. It gets most of its laughs by playing on tired male-female stereotypes (something Seinfeld likes to put twists on -- remember the "Mimbo" episode?) and just plain LAME kid's jokes. I'm not saying that Seinfeld is the best show ever made, but at its absolute best I've laughed more at tiny little jokes than at a WHOLE episode of Home Improvement. Tim Allen can take his power tools and...

Like I said, it's too easy.

Dave Platt [email]
------------------------------------

Oh, and I almost forgot, fellow babies... BOOGER!

Peter BeaupreTristan A. Farnon

In article , [email] (Tristan A. Farnon) wrote:

In general, you are correct. That is one of the great things about the show. There's not even the temptation to try to write in laughs for a cute kid. But, I do remember 2 (anyone remember more) instances where kids appeared very successfully. 1) The episode where George and Kramer's friend were fighting for the space outside Jerry's apartment to watch the boxing match. While out there mediating, Jerry accidentally mentions to a kid that his father lost his job. Hilarious.

2) The frozen yoghurt episode (I think) where Jerry accidentally curses in front of a kid.

I think these examples clearly show that Jerry isn't good with kids. Not on purpose, just that he makes mistakes like those. That's part of the humor. He's so much like a kid himself, and he just doesn't think when he does talk to a kid.

Peter Beaupre | "Now with the wisdom of years, [email] | I'm trying to reason things out, ______________________| And the only people I fear Are those who never have doubts."
Roy Eassaamd

[email] writes:

What do you expect from somebody that thinks "alot" is a word?

Michael Motodaagarwalln

AM>Home improvement is a lot better than Seinfeld. alot funnier.

Both shows are funny in their own way. I love Tim Allen, but a lot of the supporting cast (mainly the children) annoy me at times, whereas I've grown to love all the characters in Seinfeld (even all the one-shot extras... they really know how to pick em). I watch both shows a lot, but I do think that Jerry wouldn't be half as funny without the marvelous trio he shares the stage with. Hmm... that kinda reminds me that I HAVEN'T been watching HI that much... is Lisa still on there? She's cute.

  • SLMR 2.1a * That's my dream... it's my nightmare
Michael Motodaagarwalln

CM>> Home improvement is a lot better than Seinfeld. alot funnier.

CM>Why would you bother to put a comment like this in this particular CM>newsgroup? Are you a glutton for punishment???

Just an opinion, I suppose. Not backed up with any information is a no-no when criticizing another work, but I suppose it's better to argue intelligently than criticize someone else for liking another show. I've had BAD experiences in Star Trek and Amiga echos, and this one seems to have the flavor that I'm looking for. I feel very at home here even though this is my first day in here.

  • SLMR 2.1a * The horror... the horror....
Rick Paliagarwalln

. 15 Mar 94 22:36, Roy Eassa wrote:

RE> What do you expect from somebody that thinks "alot" is a word?

Good call Roy! <grin>

Rick. CRITICAL MASS [email] Internet the home of ECSTASY 1:163/328 FidoNet
Michael Motodaagarwalln

PB>2) The frozen yoghurt episode (I think) where Jerry accidentally curses in PB>front of a kid.

Haha, that was a pretty daring episode, but not any worse (and in fact, it was a lot better than) than edited-for-TV movies. That was kinda like the episode where everyone wants their keys back (i.e.: George: "Maybe because it's a crock of sh...", Elaine: "Probably because it's complete BULLsh...", etc.). My favorite one from the frozen yogurt episode was when Jerry says, "What the **** are you doing you little piece of ****?!" and then Elaine and George are going off in the kitchen...

PB>I think these examples clearly show that Jerry isn't good with kids. Not on PB>purpose, just that he makes mistakes like those. That's part of the humor. PB>He's so much like a kid himself, and he just doesn't think when he does PB>talk to a kid.

Too true. That's the whole concept behind his character and it worked great in that particular episode.

  • SLMR 2.1a * Not that there's anything wrong with that!