Unsolved Mysteries. Well, two anyway...

Jul 16, 1999, 6:46 AM ET18 posts by 14 posters
Question🙂 Liked it
18 posts
LoydM

So I have two things from Seinfeld eps that I have never been given an explanation for :

   a) "The Smelly Car".
         Just what the hell is that smell ? It can't be BO as is
         assumed in the beginning, Am I to believe that it is indeed
         a supernatural phenomenon ? Tell me !
   b) "The Pie"
         Why doesn't Jerry's girlfriend taste the apple pie ?
          I don't believe that she's too full either. There's more to
         that refusement... Maybe the chef at Monk's doesn't wash
         hands either and she saw it. Why ? Why ? You can understand
        why such a thing would prey on my mind !
         That's all. And you've probably already discussed these as
          well but I haven't and I can't sleep thinking about them.

loydM

LoydM wrote:

I think it was BO. BBO?

Seinfeld Mysteries ============= Why did she not eat the pie Newman's first name Newman/Jerry why did they hate each other Who really won the contest Jerry/George 's siblings What was George's payroll task What was Jerry's move Why did she wear the same dress

- The News Guy (Mike)'s - Seinfeld Lists Site - - http://www.geocities.com/TelevisionCity/Studio/1955/ - - MOVIES-SCRIPTS-DEATHS-FOOD-MEDICAL-CLOTHES-TRIVIA- ... -
LoydMhomerr..2.1k

On Fri, 16 Jul 1999 20:23:53 -0700, "homerr.." wrote:

   Yeah well...I still don't believe that was the
   cause of the smell.

loydM

DFrank1068LoydM

Loyd,

Is it easier to believe that Susan Ross licked toxic posion and died? Or that a mechanic would fallin love with a car and stealit from it's owner? The fact is the smell in the car was caused by the valet at the resturant. That is how Seinfeld explained it. There was not any other cause for the smell offered or needed. Classic sitcom case of over exaggerating a situation for comic effect.

LoydMDFrank1068

On 17 Jul 1999 17:17:31 GMT, [email] (DFrank1068) wrote:

fine then...point taken I guess.

loydM

Brian OConaillDFrank1068

I totally agree. It is not meant to be understood. I think the same can be said for something I've seen debated here before - Kramer's income. I think it's supposed to be an inexplicable mystery. Any little bits and pieces he picks up over the course of the program do not really explain how he always has whatever money he needs but it's an essential part of his character that he never worries about cash. I think it's things like that (and the never-ending ludicrous coincidences) that make Seinfeld unique.

DFrank1068 wrote in message ...

that

resturant.

smell

Try not to lose too much sleep over this. Meanwhile, there was an answer to this question that was mentioned right in the show, but which nobody has ever suggested as the actual reason. Right after they had eaten Jerry asked her if she was full, and she answered that she had had "just enough." She had eaten exactly as much as she wanted before pie, and did not want to add pie to this perfect comfort level. Having pie in addition to "just enough" would have been "too much". She may be just the type of person who doesn't appreciate overindulging once in a while.

Sent via Deja.com http://www.deja.com/ Share what you know. Learn what you don't.
GummoLoydM

My Seinfeld mystery is in THe Dealership, when George has to borrow a dollar from Jerry to buy a Twix, where does he get the money to buy all the candy bars in the candy bar line-up?

DaveGummo

He borrowed it.

-----------------------------------------------------------------
                           [email]
          (Hammer nail here--> <-- for a new monitor.)
Seinfeld FAQ http://www.geocities.com/Hollywood/Set/7217/faq.html
-----------------------------------------------------------------
*NOTE*  I am not responsible for equipment damage due to reeeealy
dumb children with no parental supervision, and access to a hammer.
jburdoDave

In article , [email] wrote:

given

indeed

to

understand

as

them.

a

all

I think he had the money, he just thought Jerry should pay for it. Or he used a credit card.

Sent via Deja.com http://www.deja.com/ Share what you know. Learn what you don't.
Joemoviejburdo

That's what I always figured, I mean he was there because of Jerry, and he was penny pinching George, so he asked for a dollar from Jerry...he did, however have money anyway...

Keith DavenportGummo

Gummo wrote:

And where did he buy them? The machine was out of Twix. If there was a store nearby that sold them, why didn't he just go there in the first place?

John FogdeLoydM

The one mystery, which has always bothered me the most is why Jerry's girlfriend, who dresses like a superhero always wears the same dress. They never explain it and it drove me nuts.

John

Keith DavenportJohn Fogde

John Fogde wrote:

One of two things: either they thought it was funnier not knowing, or they simply couldn't think of a funny explanation.

I guess most of us have formed our own theories on it. Anyone want to share theirs?