George's "Curb Wife" Amanda, same Amanda the He met in the Seinfeld Diner ??

Sep 13, 2010, 8:22 PM ET8 posts by 3 posters
Question

Fans discuss whether George's girlfriend Amanda from Curb Your Enthusiasm appeared in Seinfeld, clarifying that different actresses played similar characters in each show.

8 posts
JG

And got the Yankee's job thru ??

osmiumJG

"JG" wrote:

Girl:

"I'm Victoria, hi".

*That* Amanda?

What an incredible smile she gave him! It could compete with Elaine in full flirt mode.

Dimitrios Paskoudniakisosmium

"osmium" wrote in message news:[email]...

The character of "Victoria" in Seinfeld's "The Opposite" was portrayed by Dedee Pfeiffer.

The character of "Virginia" in Season 7 of "Curb Your Enthusiasm" who portrayed "Amanda" in the Seinfeld reunion was portrayed by Elisabeth Shue.

JGDimitrios Paskoudniakis

On Sep 14, 5:59 pm, "Dimitrios Paskoudniakis" wrote:

Yup, you guys are right. I was expecting too much by having one of the NBC supporting characters carried thru to Curb. But it could have worked if Amanda was instead named Victoria.

Dimitrios PaskoudniakisJG

"JG" wrote in message news:[email]... On Sep 14, 5:59 pm, "Dimitrios Paskoudniakis" wrote:

Yup, you guys are right. I was expecting too much by having one of the NBC supporting characters carried thru to Curb. But it could have worked if Amanda was instead named Victoria.

+++++++++++++++++++++++++

I'm not sure what you're getting at, but quite a few actors have been in both shows. Besides the main Seinfeld cast and some Seinfeld characters in the Seinfeld reunion on Curb (George's mother, Newman, and Banya), these include (and there are more)

Philip Baker Hall (Bookman the Library Cop on Seinfeld, Dr. Morrison on Curb) Vicki Lewis (Ada, George's secretary on Seinfeld, Stacy, Larry David's Seinfeld reunion production assistant on Curb) Christine Taylor (Ellen, Jerry's loser girlfriend on Seinfeld, herself as Ben Stiller's girlfriend on Curb) Kathy Griffin (Sally Weaver on Seinfeld, herself on Curb) Brenda Strong (Sue Ellen Mischke on Seinfeld, podiatrist on Curb)

"Dimitrios Paskoudniakis" wrote in message news:i6rvmu$5e7$[email]...

Patrick Bristow (Ethan the gay wigmaster on Seinfeld, Steve the gay choreographer on Curb Your Enthusiasm)

JGDimitrios Paskoudniakis

On Sep 18, 8:42 am, "Dimitrios Paskoudniakis" wrote:

No doubt actors have gotten roles on both Seinfeld and Curb. But you'd think that a "character" like George's wife in the Curb version of Seinfeld would have a back story in the original. Thats why "Victoria" would make sense as Mrs. Constanza on Curb. Victoria is attracted to a "unemployed Queens resident" and even gets him a job.

So basically now Jerry and Larry owe us a final NBC reunion show to at least explain how George and Amanda met.

Dimitrios PaskoudniakisJG

"JG" wrote in message news:[email]... On Sep 18, 8:42 am, "Dimitrios Paskoudniakis" wrote:

No doubt actors have gotten roles on both Seinfeld and Curb. But you'd think that a "character" like George's wife in the Curb version of Seinfeld would have a back story in the original. Thats why "Victoria" would make sense as Mrs. Constanza on Curb. Victoria is attracted to a "unemployed Queens resident" and even gets him a job.

So basically now Jerry and Larry owe us a final NBC reunion show to at least explain how George and Amanda met.

++++++++++++++++++

OK, understand, you're asking about characters who were on Seinfeld then were on the Curb Seinfeld reunion. Again the main four plus George's mother, Banya, and Newman. Why would one expect a link of Amanda to the Seinfeld show? George was engaged to Susan and she died. He was then unattached through the series finale in 1998. Curb's Seinfeld reunion season was in 2009, 11 years later, about 1/7 of a lifetime. Alot can happen in 11 years, including meeting someone, marrying them, divorcing them, and then trying to remarry them, all after May 1998. I have no expectation that Amanda would have a tie to Seinfeld. Apparently George had not yet met Amanda when the Seinfeld series ended in 1998. No explanation is needed nor owed.

Also, the entire 7th season of Curb shows that the role of Amanda is to be casted and auditioned. In your scenario, it would have been pre-determined. Larry David wanted his ex-wife to portray Amanda in order to have her see him at work to promote a reconciliation, and it worked. At the 11th hour, his ex-wife quits and they cast Virginia (Elisabeth Shue) to portray Amanda. Thus, the actress who portrays Amanda cannot have ties to the original Seinfeld series.