1/29 Episode Comment

S09E13 The CartoonliveJan 29, 1998the same night9 posts by 9 posters
😂 Loved it🔥 Controversial

Fans praise the episode's tight writing, excellent timing, and standout jokes, particularly Newman's line about the show being about something and Kramer's silent pantomime struggles.

9 posts
SLGbchh

SPOILERS FOR 1/29 EPISODE FOLLOW...DON'T READ IF HAVEN'T SEEN...

Just got through watching tonight's episode on tape, and have to say it was one of the funniest SEINFELDS ever (it was also probably one of the funniest sitcom half hours period). Extremely surprised/shocked at two posts I read before writing this one, about how the show sucked. Can't argue against opinion, but I have to say, I can't see anyone not liking this one.

What made it so well-received for me was the tight writing. The jokes were composed and configurated for maximum timing delivery. A good example of this was a couplet featuring what will probably go down as one of the best lines uttered during any SEINFELD ever. If you'll recall, Newman approaches the anti-Jerry woman in the java-house and expresses his admiration, mentioning that it's so nice to see a show that's not about nothing (or about something, I forget how he worded it)...then, we see mute-Kramer encounter the impracticality of his rash, impulsive decision when he enters a cab and the cabbie inquires as to where he wants to go, leaving mute-Kramer once again shellshocked by one of his stupid schemes. The whole episode seemed to work like that: good, solid jokes backed up by proper placement and pacing.

Another good illustration of what I'm talking about is Elaine's (and by the way, she really is a cutie, especially the way she gave Jerry her wiggle of superiority at being in the New Yorker) cartoon in the upscale magazine. She's so proud and shows the joke to Jerry, who then proceeds to express his nonchalant attitude towards it and make the blasphemous suggestion that the pig should've complained about his apartment being a stye...that was hilarious precisely because it was not only funny that Jerry was reacting negatively to Elaine's proud moment, but he rebuffed her pride with a joke that was genuinely funnier than Elaine's. Then, the rhythm was kept afloat by mute-Kramer's written suggestion of the pig reciting: My wife is a slut, a somewhat lame non sequitur, totally in keeping with Kramer's dumb, illogical wit. The whole show was like this, with joke after joke feeding off each other and fueling each other, causing a combustion of belly laughs across the Nielsen families (at least, that's what I'm theoretically- and biasedly- imagining). There also was a proper balance: we saw what we needed to see of Kramer/Elaine/George/Newman/Peterman and not a second more, not a second less. The dynamics were handled well, and the show was static not in the least. I thoroughly enjoyed it. A+....

I liked the episode, but even if it had sucked, I'll watch anything with Tracy Nelson (except for that stupid show where she played a nun).

Dave AdamsSLGbchh

SLGbchh wrote:

Don't worry about whiners.

He said, "show about something". It was a great line and I loved it. :)

Mute Kramer was as hilarious as ever.

She looked great too.

It was marvelous. Jerry was awesome as always.

I agree wholeheartedly. It was an excellent episode.

maro

DKSLGbchh

SLGbchh wrote:

I agree with everything you said. Two awesome lines were Newman's "It's so nice to see a show about SOMETHING" and George's "I'm in weird trouble"

Although one thing you didn't mention was the whole thing with that lady insulting Jerry. I'd have trouble complimenting that part of the show, too. She got old after a while.

-DK

This was the first truly classic episode of this season. People that say it sucked do not have an understanding of the ingredients of a classic Seinfeld episode.

DaveChuck Ungar

In , The Nerve writes:

Really.  Especially the first post.  Who was it ( Recordhead? )
who said the episode sucked after watching the first 8 minutes.
Now there is an opinion I cannot possibly take seriously.
--------------------------------------------
             [email]
(Hammer nail here--> <-- for a new monitor.)
          (Remove XXXX to reply)

I would be hard pressed to say that that was the best 1/2 hour of sitcom ever or the best Seinfeld ever....It had some funny parts...the girlfriend's Jerry do...Kramer miming Frank and Estelle reacting to hearing about George's "man love for a she-Jerry"....I am really glad you enjoyed it...I watched it twice....and I enjoyed it.

SLGbchh wrote in article ...

was one

sitcom

before

opinion, but

were

this

lines

the

mentioning

something, I

the

again

work

the

of

She's

the pig

hilarious

negatively to

genuinely

lame non

whole show

each

(at

also was

less.

I

I agree totally! I really do not understand all the negitive comments about this episode. I just loved the part where George thinks it would be perfect if he could have the same relationship with a woman that he has with Jerry but with the bonus of sex!

I too thought the show was great, I practically laughed from start to finish.

-Billie- I don't look busy, because I did it right the first time!