Babu

S09E08 The BetrayalliveNov 25, 19975 days later14 posts by 14 posters
Question

Viewers discuss whether Babu from Pakistan could plausibly appear at a wedding in India, with some noting Pakistan was historically part of India and others defending the show's comedic license.

14 posts
shaunh

I don't see how Babu could have shown up at the wedding in India, when Babu was from Pakistan (sp?). The last time I looked at an atlas, Pakistan was not part of India.

ShaunH

[email] wrote:

Good God man, it's a comedy show. Loosen up! lol

Rick

In article , wrote:

Babu was from Pakistan (sp?).

So what's the big deal, Pakistan is the northern neighbor (one of a few). We have Canadians visit the USA all the time. I think it would have been a good time to have Babu drop by and paly some role. Hey, its only a TV show!

JG

I thought Babu might show up too, but maybe somebody realized that India and Pakistan are mortal enemies and thought better of it.

Radcliffe Bond wrote in message ...

Yeah, thats true...but remember, this is Seinfeld, where the motto is "never let the facts get in the way of a good plot" Dale "][nkster" Crossley

[email] wrote in article ...

Babu was from Pakistan (sp?).

No, but it was part of India before India gained independence from the UK. Basically Pakistan was an area of India with an Islamic majority, so it became its own country. Y'see, "Gandhi" was on Showtime today, so the details are pretty fresh. =) So Babu showing up isn't that far-fetched.

Rich Hornshaunh

[email] wrote:

Well, the gang travelled all the way from New York.

The point that people are trying to make is not that Babu is from India. He is not. Nobody has said that he is.

The gang travelled so far, to a part of the world NEAR where Babu is. It just seems like a lost opportunity to bring back a funny character and tie in the new season to the past.

oshaunh

SO? He can travel cant he? [email] wrote in message ...

was from Pakistan (sp?).

Guy Ridleyo

NO, he can't travel! He's saving up every rupee, remember, so he can return to American and have revenge!

But when?????

Well, nuts, I have yet to see the episode with Babu in it and I hear so much about this character all the time!

Jennifer

"o" wrote:

Yes, of course he can travel, but then by the same logic you're using, the trip to India might also have been a good time to reunite the group with, say, Mr. Bookman. After all, he COULD travel to India and bump into them.

Sheesh.

Best, WT

Really! Although I suppose that if the NBC feed goes as far as Pakistan, then Babu might have caught all of the hype, or maybe the Larry King interview, then he would have known Jerry was attending a wedding in India, and he could have arranged to hook up with him.

Actually, with all that went on in that episode, where would the writers
have found time for a whole 'Babu returns' plotline??  No way.  if and
when he ever returns, I'm assuming it'll be a major part of the plot of
that particular episode.
--------------------------------------------
             [email]
(Hammer nail here--> <-- for a new monitor.)
          (Remove XXXX to reply)
The News Guy-(Mike)Dave

<snip>

Dave, that is ridicuwus! Even if Babu saw the Larry King/Seinfeld interview he could not have possibly gone to India to confront Jerry because it would have been TOO LATE. The show had already been taped. Jerry and the gang were already back in New York. Oh wait a minute; it was backwards. They returned to New York before the wedding, yeah perhaps it could happen. :-)

I could imagine a shot of Babu in his living room, with his family, watching TV and the CNN interview comes on - he recognizes Jerry, points to the set and exclaims, That's him that's the very very bad man. - fade to a commercial.

DisneDudeshaunh

In the trip to India in the Betrayal, wouldn't it have been nice if Babu showed up. Yes, I know he was deported to Pakisatain, but with all the other inconsistences it could happen.