So, why did Poppy's daughter...

S05E15 The PieretroSep 14, 2003, 4:51 AM ET10 years later8 posts by 6 postersalt.tv.seinfeld
❓ Question

Fans discuss why Poppy's daughter refused to taste Jerry's pie at Monks, with suggestions that she was difficult or had eaten the pie many times before.

8 posts
Gall546alt.tv.seinfeld

So, why did Poppy's daughter refuse to taste Jerry's pie when they were at Monks? I don't get it.

Frogiswrong↩ Noonealt.tv.seinfeld

Well , I think weve proven who the psycho is.

"Noone" wrote in message news:[email]...

at

after all, she's had the apple pie MANY TIMES.

"Frogiswrong" wrote in message news:bk1dk5$o72pf$[email]...

were

paul d valenti↩ Gall546alt.tv.seinfeld

I was on a Prodigy forum a few years ago and someone said it was because Jerry took a bite from the pie before he offered it to her. "Gall546" wrote in message news:[email]...

at