Susan's death was FUNNY

S07E24 The InvitationsretroMay 30, 19962 weeks later24 posts by 16 posters
😂 Loved it🔥 Controversial

Fans debate whether Susan's death in the wedding episode was funny, with disagreement over finding comedy in fictional deaths versus real-world tragedies.

24 posts
JCS21212

<Everyone who was at my place watching it with me was laughing <hysterically, especially when Susan died!! Isn't there anyone in this <newsgroup who appreciated the event purely for its comedic effect?

I'll bet you were disappointed when the news of the Bosnian ceasefire came through. Man, I can't even imagine how much you must have laughing when those pictures of people being maimed and killed by artillery fire were on the news. How reassuring it must have for you when China threatened Taiwan last month and the Israeli peace process was derailed by the Likud Party and suicide bombers. I'm sure you'll be on the edge of your seat this June, praying for another Communist takeover in Russia so that they can fight to reunify the USSR.

"Either you are completely for me, or you're completely against me."

"Either you are completely for me, or you're completely against me."

Everyone who was at my place watching it with me was laughing hysterically, especially when Susan died!! Isn't there anyone in this newsgroup who appreciated the event purely for its comedic effect?

In article ,

Haha.. what was that about a guy using hyperbole having already lost his argument?

What does Bosnian people getting maimed by artillery fire, China's threats to Taiwan, and the Israeli peace process have to do with Seinfeld?

Am I in the "world news" newsgroup or what?

/|Duncan Koerber "...pigs, too frequent at our tables, ... are ||Erindale College no way comparable in taste or magnificence to a \|University of Toronto well-grown fat, yearling child..." - Swift

<Haha.. what was that about a guy using hyperbole having already lost his argument?

What does Bosnian people getting maimed by artillery fire, China's threats to Taiwan, and the Israeli peace process have to do with Seinfeld?

Am I in the "world news" newsgroup or what? >

Someone thought the final episode was funny and I was merely expressing my deepest sympathy for fact that they can't see as much death on the news anymore, since they seem to find it so funny.

"Don't you worry Mr. Simpson. I've argued in front of every judge in this state, often as a lawyer." Lionel Hutz

In article ,

Death in comedy is funny. Death in real life is not (unless you really hate the guy.) :)

/|Duncan Koerber "...pigs, too frequent at our tables, ... are ||Erindale College no way comparable in taste or magnificence to a \|University of Toronto well-grown fat, yearling child..." - Swift

<Death in comedy is funny. Death in real life is not (unless you really <hate the guy.) :) <--

Death is death is death. It's either funny or its not. It doesn't matter whether its real or not, since it represents the same thing.

"Don't you worry Mr. Simpson. I've argued in front of every judge in this state, often as a lawyer." Lionel Hutz

[email] (JCS21212) wrote:

Except that it's TV, so no one really died.... you DID know that, didn't you?

In the words of Helen Hunt, there are two reasons that you shouldn't take Seinfeld so seriously:

(1) It's just a TV show.

(2) IT'S JUST A TV SHOW!!!

------> [email] (Doctor Fang) <------ "Cheese: nature's toothbrush."

[email] (Doctor Fang) wrote:

I think she was refering to the Evening News. :)

Monty

"A cigar may be just a cigar, but Lanie, now she's a smoke." -- W.T. 'Doc' Pfefferle, PhD.

< (1) It's just a TV show.

(2) IT'S JUST A TV SHOW!!!>

I can't help but think I've heard this argument before. I'm sure it sounds familiar. Maybe you should restate it about four dozen more times and I'll remember. As for you substantive point, whether real or not death should still be disturbing. Obviously it isn't since you psychos think its funny but then thats to be expected from a country in decline. Rome became obsessed with bloodsports during its last centuries too.

"Don't you worry Mr. Simpson. I've argued in front of every judge in this state, often as a lawyer." Lionel Hutz

[email] (JCS21212) wrote:

Seinfeld pokes fun at *everything*. It's hard to take something seriously unless you've given yourself a chance to laugh about it. Why do you think people like Steve Forbes or George Steinbrenner go on SNL? The entire hour and a half is spent making fun of them. They do it to show that *they can laugh at themselves*. I don't think death is funny. I feel sorry for the people who die in slasher films, okay? I just think that, when done well in a show that's supposed to be funny, that you can laugh at anything. Besides, most of the humor was not in the death itself, but in the reaction to the death, which was really saying the same thing you did: people don't care about death anymore.

PS. What did you think of the episode where Jerry goes to tell jokes to the sick guy and he laughs so hard that he dies? Or the one where George kills Mr. Peterman's mother by telling her his ATM PIN number (Bosco!)?

/----------------------------Joshua Hall-Bachner----------------------------\ | [email] http://www.servtech.com/public/particle/ | | "I spend too much time raiding windmills. We go side by side, laugh until | \-------it's right." Toad The Wet Sprocket, "Windmills"---------------------/

Statement 1 seems to say that all deaths -- real or fictional -- are the same, and so presumably unfunny.

Statement 2 seems to leave open the possibility that some deaths (presumably some of the fictional ones) are funny.

Statement 3 sounds like statement 1.

So which is it? Are some (fictional) deaths funny or not?

Bob Teeter ([email]) | "Write me a few of your lines" http://www.wco.com/~rteeter/ | --Mississippi Fred McDowell Contra CDA: Reproductive health info is available from Planned Parenthood, 1691 The Alameda, San Jose, CA 95126 (408) 287-7526
ScomanJCS21212

Grow up, it's a TV show.

Scoman's Homepage Musician/Web page designer/Scanning service/Graphic and computer art http://www.sysconn.com/Scoman/scoman1.htm
turtleScoman

or ten other no-brainer sit-coms I could name. They seem to be funny at first untill that fatal "Tragedy strikes the set of..........." were one of the characters has a life threatening problem. Hey it's a FREEKEN COMEDY!!!! and when you start taking yourself seriously it's time to quit.

Seinfeld is great because it is a comedy and I hope it stays that way.

My opinion and I am Gary

JCS21212Scoman

<Grow up, it's a TV show.

Brilliant deduction, Holmes. What tipped you off: the fact it was on television or the fact that the characters were actors?

"Don't you worry Mr. Simpson. I've argued in front of every judge in this state, often as a lawyer." Lionel Hutz

I thought her death was HORRIBLE. How in the hell could you laugh at someone's death...It's STILL my favorite show (the ASSMAN episode the best), but the last one of the season was a real downer...

ummm...because it wasn't real? You didn't like "Weekend at Bernie's" or "The Trouble With Harry" did you?

*************************************************************************************************************
"People think it must be fun to be a super genius, but they don't realize how hard it is putting up with all the idiots in the world."--Calvin

"We know that the nature of genius is to provide idiots with ideas twenty years later."--Louis Aragon

Susan was sumbuddy's baby once...YEAH, HER DEATH WAS ABOUT AS GODDAMNED FUNNY AS O.J. PICKING UP NICOLE'S LIFELESS HEAD AND SLICING HER THROAT TO MAKE SURE THE WHITE BITCH WAS DEAD, PAL!! :-(

Friend, you are so mercifully free from the ravages of intelligence.

Can you tell the difference between real and make-believe? Maybe you are the one without intelligence.

TV characters were never anyone's baby. They are just characters created by a writer. It doesn't make a difference if they die.

Of course, they're not real...Yes, but you see, couldn't the characters show remorse for another character who the writers did not make evil or mean? I was waiting for the punch line that never came...I left the ending with an eerie feeling, one I never got from any

Am I the only one who thinks Susan faked her death to get out of marrying George since he spent the whole episode trying to do just that? -James

debbieSYDB1367

[email] (SYDB1367) wrote:

yes Debbie ([email]) Dallas,TX

Perhaps this will be the last time you use this argument, since most people have caught on to the fact that you are the only one who has confused the news with a situation comedy.