Seinfeld in Europe

Aug 18, 2001, 5:28 PM ET26 posts by 14 postersalt.tv.seinfeld
Question
26 posts
Bernard Grychowskialt.tv.seinfeld

Hello,

I would like to know in which country Seinfeld is on air now, especially UK, Spain, Switzerland and Nederlands

In France it's on Canal+, and for holydays 1 episode per day, now season 9

Thanks

Enlevez ZZ pour repondre Bernard Marseille, France

"Bernard Grychowski" wrote in message news:9lmmll$e4l$[email]...

especially UK,

season 9

In UK, on the Paramount Comedy Channel everyday at 5.30pm. Currently on Season 5, last episode was The Marine Biologist.

Jan
SophieDavealt.tv.seinfeld

On Sun, 19 Aug 2001 14:34:21 -0400, Dave wrote:

I have two different episodes, twice a day each.

Nananananaaaaaanaaaaaaaaaa.

Sophie

MGBernard Grychowskialt.tv.seinfeld

"Bernard Grychowski" schrieb im Newsbeitrag news:9lmmll$e4l$[email]...

UK,

In Germany it runs every day on Premiere Digital, Pay-TV that requires a set-top box. They show the entire 180 episodes(?), which works out to about 6 months on a daily basis, and then tehy wait 6 months and start again. It's in Geman, which is shame, but as far as dubbing goes, it's state-of-the-art. Oh yes, it is also shown weekly on Pro7.

SophieMGalt.tv.seinfeld

On Sun, 19 Aug 2001 17:57:35 +0200, "MG" wrote:

This reminds me of the gawd awful version of Seinfeld dubbed in French that was shown in Qu�bec many years ago. It was so bad, it hurt. Thank Eros, it was canned after a few months.

What I never understood was the dialect chosen to dub the series; Seinfeld was dubbed in "French-French" as opposed to "Qu�bec-French", which was a mistake in my opinion. In comparison, The Simpsons dubbed in Qu�bec-French is at least as good as the original and has been shown for many years. Similarly, the Qu�bec-French version of The Flintstones is a classic. (I once saw a French-French version of The Simpsons and it was unbearable.)

How many of our European friends see dubbed versions of Seinfeld? Are they any good?

Is it possible to successfully dub a sitcom in a foreign language? What are the elements that ensure a successful translation? Are the cases of The Flintstones and The Simpsons different because they are animated (as opposed to live-action)?

Sophie

MGSophiealt.tv.seinfeld

"Sophie" schrieb im Newsbeitrag news:[email]...

about

It's

state-of-the-art.

Believe me, I have almost every Seinfeld in the original (from US TV) and English is still my best language, but the German version is good! Even the voices sound uncannily the same, except Newman, for whom they surprisingly chose a very high-pitched one. There are a few glaring errors of translation, though. In fact, the whole episode 'The Fatigues' was named 'Erm�dungserscheinungen', which means 'symptoms of fatigue', as in being tired! Never mind that the guy wears his camouflage fatigues the whole time and that Elaine actually asks him what's up with those. They just settled for 'tiredness' and nobody bothered to look up a dictionary. Go figure...

In article , [email]. says...

In France, the dubbed version is also awful. Now on Canal +, it's the best system : multi lingual : you can choose french or english with french subtitles with the remote. You can even remove french subtitles, it is an undocumented option because french law on language requires subtitles. A couple of years ago, it was aired on Canal Jimmy, a very goog channel in english (with french subtitles of course).

The problem (with Canal + and Canal Jimmy) in the order of episode, with is not good. They take production order, and not the order which is used in the US and everywhere I guess. The Puerto Rican day is normaly aired, but for the Contest was dropped on Canal + (not on Canal Jimmy). Some people told because it was just after the death of JFK junior

On 19 Aug 2001 22:19:32 GMT, [email] (Bernard Grychowski) wrote:

It's probably the same version they tried to show us in Qu�bec. It is hard enough to sell us a comedy dubbed in France, when it is bad to begin with, I wonder why they even bother.

How cool, just like a DVD. This would be a digital channel? I hope we get something similar here some day.

You have language laws as well? I thought only the gaddamm separatisss had those.

In syndication, we don't get them in the order they were shown in the first run. It goes back and forth from one season to the next (at least here, it does).

In article , [email]. says...

[SNIP]

Cool, but very expensive. There are a rumor that it's the most expensive channel in the world, something like 20US$ a month.

Yes, each frech channel must be in French or with french subtitle. Even MTV has subtitles. There are very few exceptions : CNN, NBC. Another special law is that on french channel an important ratio of film must be produced by french.

But inside a season, is the original order respected ? For example for 5th season the order in France is : 5.1,5.3,5.2,5.4,5.5,5.6,5.8,5.7,5.9, 5.10,5.11,5.12,5.14, 5.13,5.15,5.16,5.17,5.20,5.18,5.19,5.22,5.21 The finale of the season is not even respected.

Enlevez ZZ pour repondre Bernard Marseille, France

On 20 Aug 2001 21:18:12 GMT, [email] (Bernard Grychowski) wrote:

<edited for space>

How very interesting... The language laws here are very controversial; the language law opponents usually say "In Europe, they don't have stupid laws like these". Hmmm....

<snippedy snip>

They seem to be shown completely at random. I can't see any logic in the order. (Then again I flunked math in high school, something I tell my college students every chance I get.)

Tod FriendlySophiealt.tv.seinfeld

"Sophie" wrote in message news:[email]...

MTV

must

There are limits on the %age of non-French music which can be played on the radio as well.

Tod Friendly "Who loves not wisely but too well, will look on Helen's face in Hell. But he whose love is thin and wise,

In article , [email]. says...

must

I think it's not in every european country, for exemple I saw sometimes no subtitles in Spain in Switzerland

It's not random order. It's production order, which is (I think, but I'm not sure) the order or taping. See for example : www.epguides.com/seinfeld/

For example the Stranded 3.10 was taped during the second season, but was aired in the third season. Its production number is 209. In france, this episode is aired with the second season, which is not the case in the Netherland and all other country I guess.

There is the same problem with Dream On aired on Canal Jimmy. I have a fight with the program manager, and he told me that he checks with the production, and that this order is good, which lead to incoherency in the story. Sometimes french mangers are a bit annoying when they think there are the best and that they are right against all the world :-)

Enlevez ZZ pour repondre Bernard Marseille, France

On 21 Aug 2001 08:41:23 GMT, [email] (Bernard Grychowski) wrote:

Yes, I got the point about them being shown according to the production order in France. What I was saying is, here, in North America, the episodes are shown in random order.

Vieux gag qu�b�cois : Quelle est la diff�rence entre un Fran�ais et un maudit Fran�ais? Le maudit Fran�ais, c'est celui qui reste.

Ian F.Sophiealt.tv.seinfeld

"Sophie" wrote in message news:[email]...

Mais est-il le ma�tre de son domaine?

Ian

Ray GoudieSophiealt.tv.seinfeld

No, many countries have laws that promote the national language. Separatists, however, only pass laws that suppress languages that the separatists have a grudge against to the point of changing the motto of the provincial license plate from "La Belle Province" ("The Beautiful Province") to the less-than-admirable "Je Me Souviens" ("I Remember").

                            -Ray.

"Sophie" wrote in message news:[email]...

MohamelRay Goudiealt.tv.seinfeld

"Ray Goudie" a �crit dans le message news: 4Phg7.18925$[email]...

the

Province")

Especially since Most Quebecois don't really remember what we are suppose to remember.. ( Including me)

Mo

Ian F.Sophiealt.tv.seinfeld

"Sophie" wrote in message news:[email]...

Over here in the UKoGBaNI, the show isn't dubbed - we get it in American! ;-)

Ian

homerr..2.1kIan F.alt.tv.seinfeld

Ian F. wrote in message ...

Do you understand it sufficiently enough to appreciate the humour??

homerr.. bachelor#3 [American]

Ian F.homerr..2.1kalt.tv.seinfeld

"homerr.. 2.1k" wrote in message news:9lpg5u$s3v$[email]...

Er, I was joking. Did you miss the ;-) ? There's very little US *humor* that I do not understand.

Ian

homerr..2.1kIan F.alt.tv.seinfeld

Ian F. wrote in message ...

LOL.. so was I Ian.. that's why I spelled it *humour*..

homerr.. bachelor#3 [mark it one for the homesterr.. ]

Ian F.homerr..2.1kalt.tv.seinfeld

"homerr.. 2.1k" wrote in message news:9lphg7$uuj$[email]...

Hehehehe...sorry. Not used to Merkins understanding irony! ;-))

Ian

In The Netherlands it's on air on NET5, on tuesday or wednesday or both days.

Marnix

Bernard Grychowski schreef in berichtnieuws 9lmmll$e4l$[email]...

UK,

That's correct And I can't follow it why it is on tuesday, and then on wednesday, and the other week only on wednesday. Next episode will be The Stranded

I use www.omroep.nl to check which episode will be on.

On Sun, 19 Aug 2001 20:38:30 +0200, "MF Izeboud" wrote:

--- 'You can stuff your sorries in a sack mister.'

Remove **nospam** to reply...