Susan, (Heidi Swedberg)?

S07E24 The InvitationsretroFeb 14, 2008, 12:43 PM ET12 years later26 posts by 12 posters
Question
26 posts
Norman M. Schwartz

Has it been discussed here, or elsewhere, why her character was written off the show?

Gerky GatzosNorman M. Schwartz

BECAUSE SHE LICKED EVNELOPES AND GOT SICK AND DIED

"Norman M. Schwartz" wrote in message news:47b47d66$0$15164$[email]... > Has it been discussed here, or elsewhere, why her character was written > off the show?
Norman M. SchwartzGerky Gatzos

"Gerky Gatzos" wrote in message news:[email]...

Your kidding right? (All along I thought it was because her cheapskate fiancee insisted on the least costly wedding invitations.)

"Norman M. Schwartz" wrote in message news:47b48b69$0$15188$[email]...

<Talking to myself> It should have been be "you're", right?

Anyway it didn't make a whole lot of sense that George insisted on the cheapest invitations. Susan was the one that was gainfully employed and the Rosses were very wealthy ("and the townhouse, no"), so he most probably wouldn't have been the one paying for the invitations.

Mark MellinNorman M. Schwartz

In article , "Norman M. Schwartz" wrote:

Maybe Mike remembers better than I do, but I don't think so. Are there any comments on that season's DVD?

People were really divided here, at the time, though as to what direction the show was taking after her last episode (not counting The Betrayal):

<http://groups.google.com/group/alt.tv.seinfeld/browse_frm/thread/eddc504a115d5d88/b927f62b1d066ebc>

  • Mark
Mark Mellin ULmar 9 - 5470 Mailstop 408-85 Menlo Park, CA 94025-3493 USA
KarenCannoliNorman M. Schwartz
"Norman M. Schwartz" wrote in message news:47b47d66$0$15164$[email]... > Has it been discussed here, or elsewhere, why her character was written off the > show?
Norman M. SchwartzKarenCannoli

"KarenCannoli" wrote in message news:[email]...

Admittedly her voice isn't of the most pleasing quality, nevertheless didn't she audition for the part, and against some serious competition at that? Perhaps the people in charge of casting and offering jobs believed her poorer voice quality more suitable for the role than other's. In any event they knew what they were getting and there being no surprises, I seriously doubt any such possibility.

Mark MellinKarenCannoli

Truly, she didn't become shrill until right before the wedding.

Though she did break the Bubble Boy's bubble.

  • Mark
Mark Mellin San Mateo Village, CA 94403 USA
Norman M. SchwartzMark Mellin

"Mark Mellin" wrote in message news:[email]...

But she had a fine cheek with a pinkish hue.

ZMANOscartheGrouch

"OscartheGrouch" wrote in message news:57itj.2$MY2.1@trndny07...

You're wearing THAT shirt??!!

OneOhEightZMAN

I believe she was written off the show because the writers were sick of having George dating the same annoying bitch forever. It gets old after a while in a show like Seinfeld, they needed a change of pace, so they killed her.

Norman M. SchwartzOneOhEight

"OneOhEight" wrote in message news:[email]...

If they ever married, why would George continue to be dating Susan?

It gets old

I guess the writers wanted to keep the show centered around the adventures of 4 singles, and not 3 singles and a married couple. The only way out would have been for George to break up with Susan once again and all the show's break ups were becoming stale material. Her demise opened up the opportunity for them to exploit new subject matter, which in fact they did.

OneOhEightNorman M. Schwartz

A married Seinfeld character would have never worked. Also it's great how nobody really even cares when Susan dies. This is what made Seinfeld so great, they removed all of the phony serious moments that all other sitcoms have, it was a show about four jerks who didn't really care about anybody else.

Norman M. SchwartzOneOhEight

"OneOhEight" wrote in message news:[email]...

How about the volunteer work with the senior citizens, (didn't George say signing up for it made him feel good?) or signining up and going on an AIDS walk? I think that shows caring about someone else.

Karl FarbmannNorman M. Schwartz

"Norman M. Schwartz" wrote in message news:47bb0f90$0$8076$[email]...

True, but didn't they all actually end up with the same selfish behavior with these "charitable" behaviors:

1. Aids Walk- Kremer up all night, playing poker, andf when it comes time for the walk,, he won't wear the ribbon.

  • Aids Walk- Jerry gets Nina's phone number from an Aids Walk list

3. Senior Citizens- George gets his bald head dipped in hot oil, Kremer and Newman take the old records that belonged to the senior that George was supposed to be spending time with.

4. George talking ot other senior citizen at Monk's asking how the sr. gets through knowing he's so close to the end?

5. Elaine is totally bored talking to her senior companion until she finds out the senior woman had an affair with Ghandi, and how the goiter made it hard for her to talk to her senior partner?

Just my 2c....

Norman M. SchwartzKarl Farbmann

"Karl Farbmann" wrote in message news:SwJuj.41062$9j6.26425@attbi_s22...

However ended up, they were intiated with good intention. Why would "jerks who didn't really care about anyone else" get involved in these endeavors?

(Now already my $0.04.)

WillNorman M. Schwartz

"Norman M. Schwartz" wrote in message news:47bb8bdf$0$8093$[email]...

Jerry tried to help Babu and the motivation seemed to be to make himself feel good.

Norman M. SchwartzWill

"Will" wrote in message news:[email]...

Indeed, and additionally Jerry went to the hospital to cheer up Fulton.

Philip WexlerNorman M. Schwartz

Maybe Susan wanted to go back to being a lesbian character on the show and the writers didn't think that was such a good idea- so they got rid of her character. After all, George drives women to lesbian-ism! (and yes, Kramer brings 'em back!). Phil

Alexis MachineWill

it's all about human nature: the show magnifies the volatility of human nature between wanting to do good (or wanting to seem to wanting to do good) and falling short on the reality of selfishness. That's the very genius of the show. That's also why the "finale" was not so funny.

"Will" wrote in message news:[email]...

Alexis MachineNorman M. Schwartz

That is discussed in the interviews that come with the DVDs although my take on it is that Larry David's mind works the way it does: I don't remember for sure but was it him who decided to write her doom?

"Norman M. Schwartz" wrote in message news:47b47d66$0$15164$[email]... > Has it been discussed here, or elsewhere, why her character was written > off the show?
WillAlexis Machine
"Alexis Machine" wrote in message news:fq1jgr$[email]... > That is discussed in the interviews that come with the DVDs although my > take on it is that Larry David's mind works the way it does: I don't