Is George really Art?

S01E01 Good News, Bad NewsretroDec 20, 2001, 1:24 PM ET12 years later10 posts by 8 postersalt.tv.seinfeld
❓ Question

Viewers debate whether Jerry calls George "Art" in the pilot episode, with discussion about whether this was a naming inconsistency or confusion with later episodes featuring Art Vandelay.

10 posts
Lee Actoralt.tv.seinfeld

In the pilot "Good News, Bad News", about 2/3 of the way through, Jerry is talking to George (wearing a British golfing hat) in his apartment, and says, "Wait a minute, Art. I didn't clean the bathroom." At least it sure sounds like that to me. Jerry definitely calls him George later in the episode.

-Lee

Maarten↩ Lee Actoralt.tv.seinfeld

"Lee Actor" schreef in bericht news:%1qU7.14034$NM4.3200225@rwcrnsc53...

sure

That's funny. But George was pretending to be Art Vandelay later on in the series...perhaps at the time of the pilot they didn't have figured out yet what Jasons character would be named like, George or Art...maybe that's why they said both names in the pilot. Geezz, this sounds stupid anyways. Good remark tho.

Have fun, Mailman

unknown↩ Lee Actoralt.tv.seinfeld

On Thu, 20 Dec 2001 15:20:33 -0500, "Casey Hoerig" wrote:

. . .

I think you have two episodes in mind - Good News Bad News was the pilot episode and George's dad is not in it. It is not until The Handicapped Spot, a few years later that we meet (any of )George's dad(s).

The News Guy(Mike) - Seinfeld Lists http://www.geocities.com/tnguym All things Seinfeld; scripts, trivia, lists,
Maarten↩ unknownalt.tv.seinfeld

episode

few

Wasn't Casey talking about Jerry's dad? Anyways, I recently saw The Handicapped Spot for the first time, I hated the guy who played George's dad. Really no good character in comparison to the *real* George's dead...SERENITY NOW! Talking about parents...I prefer George's parents above Jerry's..Jerry's parents are so soft, easy-going, George's are always screaming to each other...love it!

Mailman

The original poster was talking about Jerry's dad, not George's. But I still think you're correct that he's thinking of two episodes--the pilot and the second episode, "The Stakeout", the only episode featuring Phil Bruns as Jerry's dad.

John Twernbold jtwernbold (at) yahoo.com

In article "John Twernbold" writes:

Right. And unlike the "Handicapped Spot", "The Stakeout" was never re-shot with Jerry's new Dad for syndication.

Mark Mellin Precita Valley, CA 94110-5206 USA

What might be a good way to verify what is said, is to put on Closed Caption while watching it. This also works if it was video taped, it doesn't have to be a live broadcast.

East

Casey Hoerig wrote:

Wez in Oz↩ Lee Actoralt.tv.seinfeld

"Lee Actor" wrote in message news:...

Not saying you're wrong because I haven't seen that episode myself, but check out the script at:

http://www.geocities.com/TelevisionCity/Network/2717/Scripts/Season1/TheSeinfeldChronicals.txt

Someone else thinks the line is:

JERRY: Yeah, OK. Oh, wait a second. Oh, I, I forgot to clean the bathroom.

Lee Actor↩ Wez in Ozalt.tv.seinfeld

"Wez in Oz" wrote in message news:[email]...

news:...

is

sure

http://www.geocities.com/TelevisionCity/Network/2717/Scripts/Season1/TheSein feldChronicals.txt

I just watched the scene again. Jerry's line is definitely, "Oh, wait a second, Art. <pause> I, I forgot to clean the bathroom." Anyone else have a tape?

-Lee

"Wez in Oz" wrote in message news:[email]...

news:...

is

sure

http://www.geocities.com/TelevisionCity/Network/2717/Scripts/Season1/TheSein feldChronicals.txt

The Seinfeld Scripts (Boxtree publications) gives the line as..

JERRY: Yeah, Okay. Oh, wait a second, I forgot to clean the bathroom.

But then of course, these could be Scripts, as opposed to Transcripts, and may not be accurate to the filmed episodes.. (Not sure)