Emmys are a joke

Sep 14, 199828 posts by 12 posters
😡 Hated it🔥 Controversial

Fans debate Emmy awards and argue that Frasier wins despite Seinfeld being superior in writing and acting; some defend Frasier's quality performances.

28 posts
Joe26

Who's dick is Kelsey Grammer sucking. Frasier is not that good. It is the perennial winner for best comedy. Kelsey Grammer and David Hyde Pierce won the acting awards. Come on.

Andrew BrackJoe26

[email] (Joe26) wrote:

Try watching it. It's tasteful and funny. Grammer and Pierce DO put a lot of effort into their performances. Watch from the very begining and you'll begin to understand how quickly he (Pierce) improved - you're talking about two or three episodes to get up to perfection. As for grammer - it's certainly not YOUR dick...

But then David Hyde-Pierce is gay, so...

No really, I watch Frasier on occasion but it cannot compare to Seinfeld, either in writing or in acting, but consider that generally, most awards shows are fixed. Giving the Emmy to Frasier was the easy way out. They didn't have to put any thought into it.

"Hey, wanna watch some of the other nominees? Naaah. Just we'll give it to Frasier again. That frees up out afternoon to go play some golf."

I'm also reminded of the year, I think it was in the late 70's, where the SAG went on strike. 51 of the 52 Emmy nominees boycotted the awards show. So who do you suppose won for best actor? Powers Boothe, the only scab to cross the picket line and show up, won it for the Jim Jones/Guyana movie.

No, most of those awards shows are mere 'masturbation fests' where the
"chosen ones" slap each other on the back or jerk each other off or
whatever it is they do.  And I don't just say this because Seinfeld was
snubbed this year.  I've never cared much for any of the awards shows.
My tastes have rarely coincided with those of the voters.  Across the
board, whether it be books, movies, TV shows, with the exception of
Seinfeld, none of my favorites have ever been critically acclaimed
enough to win awards of any kind.  Watching awards shows is like peeking
into the gatherings of clubs I don't belong to.  What's the point?
-----------------------------------------------------------------
            [email]  replace EYE with I
          (Hammer nail here--> <-- for a new monitor.)
Seinfeld FAQ http://www.geocities.com/Hollywood/Set/7217/faq.html
-----------------------------------------------------------------
Andrew BrackDave

Dave wrote:

Strange really but I haven't heard of him coming out and anyway, does a person's sexual tendancies do anything to his or her performance?

I don't think so - it's all about taste. Frasier and Seinfeld have battled it out for years in the States. Over here *UK* - Frasier *ALWAYS* has good reviews and Seinfeld is only shown on Sky. It's annoying too because it's on at the same time as three other programs I want to watch...

I HIGHLY doubt that happened...

I can't be reminded of the year - I wasn't alive then...

Award shows are pointless but some are highly entertaining - I love watching the Oscars just because of the war it's presented (probably shown without any stops in the States but while there's no activity we always cut to the wonderful Barry Norman...). That's the ONLY award show I like and anyway - it's the least accurate of the lot. Titanic! - Best picture - bah, humbug...

Yes, he did come out. And it has nothing to do with his performance, or maybe it has everything to do with his performance. Niles is a rather effeminate character. Anyway, I'm not looking for an argument here, my post about DHP's sexuality was merely a joke in poor taste at the oral sex reference in the previous post. If you want to debate this ad nauseum, hit up the Frasier newsgroup.

I don't know enough about British folks to comment on their tastes.

I was being sarcastic. If you read more of my posts, you'll often find a twinge of humor here and there.

But it happened. Booth was the only one who would play their reindeer games, so he won the award. From that point on, I resolved never to take an awards show seriously. Not much has happened since then to change my mind.

Another good point.  11 awards??  Talk about the most intensive display
of bandwagon jumping since the Chicago Bulls signed Michael Jordan.
-----------------------------------------------------------------
            [email]  replace EYE with I
          (Hammer nail here--> <-- for a new monitor.)
Seinfeld FAQ http://www.geocities.com/Hollywood/Set/7217/faq.html
-----------------------------------------------------------------
Andrew BrackDave

Dave wrote:

I'm a member of the Frasier newsgroup. We haven't been informed over here - not that it matters. He's still one of my favourite actors of all time... About his performance - I personally think that he is a lot funnier than most other sitcom characters that I can think of... Did you see the Montreal Just For Laughs Comedy Festival where he did the physcologist's rap? Classic!

We like most American shows. We're pretty much rubbish at doing comedy to international tastes though. Personally my favourites are (not in any order):

Frasier Cheers Seinfeld Wings Mad About You Cosby Spin City The Simpsons

So was I... I know that you were kidding... I just wanted to get you to post a reply...

I was born in 1984 - that must have been 6 or 7 years after that incident...

David Hyde Pierce was a candidate for John\Jack\Bob\Johnny\Jackie - well, whatever the name of that annoying fool played poorly by Leo Di Caprio. DHP would have been a lot better (could have been 1 more oscar too!)

British Awards failed to give Titanic any awards - shows how much we liked it! ;-)

David Hyde-Pierce's sexual orientation is debated on (nearly) a daily basis in alt.tv.frasier. Anyone who wishes to weigh in with his opinion is encouraged to visit that newsgroup. The subject is off-topic here.

Actually, I think they're pretty kinda of discussing it there too.

So, how to we steer this back to the topic at hand?

Gay characters appearing on Seinfeld?

I thought you'd never ask!

There's the two gay street toughs who steal Elaine's armoire from Kramer, and assault kramer during the AIDS walk and the Puerto Rican Day parade.

There's Ethan, the wigmaster for "Joseph and the Amazing Technicolor Dreamcoat", and the man who tried to pick him up while he and Jerry were sipping champaign coolies.

There's the gay man Elaine tried to convert in "The Beard".

Susan (and her girlfriend) after Susan left George.

That's all off the top of my head. Any others? [email] replace EYE with I (Hammer nail here--> <-- for a new monitor.) Seinfeld FAQ http://www.geocities.com/Hollywood/Set/7217/faq.html
Rick StreeterDave

Dave wrote:

Hank....the guy that Elaine thought she was going out with instead of Jimmy in......"The Jimmy"....oh and Hanks new boyfriend.......Wasn't Georges ex Allison shown with Susan watching the pilot of "Jerry"....after she complemented Susan on her vest while George was trying to cheer her up about losing Mona to Kramer.......

Hard work has a future payoff. Laziness pays off NOW!
The News Guy(Mike)Dave

Dave wrote:

Susan's Father - How could we forget the letters.

The News Guy (Mike)'s - Seinfeld Lists Site http://www.geocities.com/TelevisionCity/Studio/1955/ 36 SCRIPTS - MOVIES - DEATHS -FOOD - MEDICAL - CLOTHES - ...

The News Guy(Mike) a �crit dans le message ...

There's that army guy who congratulates Jerry on his" coming out" in "The Outing"

Mo

DaveMohamel

Good one! "I fear my orgasm has made me a cripple." This counts as two; John Cheever and Mr. Ross.

I had forgotten about that. Great. One more and this is FAQworthy.

C'mon Mike. If *anyone* can do it, it's you. [email] replace EYE with I (Hammer nail here--> <-- for a new monitor.) Seinfeld FAQ http://www.geocities.com/Hollywood/Set/7217/faq.html
jburdoDave

In article , [email] wrote:

Bob and Ray (nee Cedrick)

George's girlfriend from "The Outing" (IIRC) who got together with Susan after the latter lost her initial girlfriend (the golf pro) to Kramer.

-----== Posted via Deja News, The Leader in Internet Discussion ==----- http://www.dejanews.com/rg_mkgrp.xp Create Your Own Free Member Forum

[email] (art vandelay) wrote:

I know - I just didn't know that it *WAS* fact. It wasn't supposed to be off-topic. It was in response to the Emmys post...

The News Guy(Mike)art vandelay

art vandelay wrote:

But what about his religion? That's what people are into here.

The News Guy (Mike)'s - Seinfeld Lists Site http://www.geocities.com/TelevisionCity/Studio/1955/ 36 SCRIPTS - MOVIES - DEATHS -FOOD - MEDICAL - CLOTHES - ...
Niraj AgarwallaDave

Dave ([email]) wrote:

Nothing can be compared to Seinfeld. What a silly notion. I am pleased that Frasier won it, especially for David Hyde Pierce.

All award shows are like that. The Oscars are a joke, the Academy basically awarded Helen Hunt an Academy Award for an over-glorified sitcom.

Agreed. Most award show are crap.

Niraj Agarwalla -- [email] -- http://www.shore.net/~niraj

You're way, way off here! The Emmys are one of a handful of Awards shows that possess at least a modicum of objectivity. Emmy winners are determined by a number of committees made up of television professionals who must (repeat, must) watch each and every nominee to determine winners. Consider that sometimes certain categories have only two nominees, sometimes six (e.g., Actress in a Comedy this year)! That at least is some indication that nominations are not just handed out willy-nilly.

The Oscar ballots are mailed out mostly to retired industry professionals who see maybe three movies a year and usually give their ballots to their secretaries. The Golden Globe winners are chosen by only 50-60 people who are easily influenced by favors and gifts (hence Pia Zadora's win in 1980). Ever notice how often Golden Globe winners DON'T win Oscars (sometimes they're not even nominated, e.g. Madonna)? "Frasier's" only real competition this year was "Ally McBeal"; "Seinfeld" didn't have a chance. Most of the people on this newsgroup have spent all year bitching about how lame this season was but now they're astounded about why it didn't win the Emmy(?). Maybe it lost because, unlike "Frasier", it ran hot and cold all season. "Frasier" is consistently amusing (not hilarious, not dull) week in and week out. That's why it has deservedly won 5 Emmys in a row.

And, oh yes, I remember when Powers Boothe won his Emmy for the Guyana tragedy movie. He was absolutely, 100%, on-the-money the most appropriate choice to win for his riveting performance. He did NOT win just because he showed up--it doesn't work that way. He rather riskily elected to appear, and no doubt received quite a few cold shoulders from his peers in years to come.

I, too, have great difficulty sitting through all awards shows. I prefer just to read a list of winners in the paper the next day and that's good enough for me. But be fair: sometimes the winner has won because he, she or it is just plain deserving.

R

Andrew BrackDave

[email] (Zippy� ) wrote:

I didn't think so. D.H.P. isn't married thus I can't understand why he said that he was married on a talk show...

Niraj AgarwallaJoe26

Joe26 ([email]) wrote:

Frasier is quite good. It has a dry wit about it. David Hyde Price deserved an Emmy years ago, but because of Seinfeld he was unable to. In my opinion, it is just a delayed award.

Niraj Agarwalla -- [email] -- http://www.shore.net/~niraj
The News Guy(Mike)Niraj Agarwalla

Niraj Agarwalla wrote:

I have seen DHP in three parts - an appearance on Dream On, the brother in Sleepless in Seattle, and Niles on Frazier. In all three he plays the same prissy character. Compare that to Jason Alexander who takes on character after character - all different - That's Acting!

The News Guy (Mike)'s - Seinfeld Lists Site http://www.geocities.com/TelevisionCity/Studio/1955/ 36 SCRIPTS - MOVIES - DEATHS -FOOD - MEDICAL - CLOTHES - ...
Yup.  And it wouldn't surprise me to learn that DHP, in real life, is
not far at all from the character he plays.  If anyone deserves an Emmy
just for playing themselves, then Jerry himself aught to top the list.
-----------------------------------------------------------------
            [email]  replace EYE with I
          (Hammer nail here--> <-- for a new monitor.)
Seinfeld FAQ http://www.geocities.com/Hollywood/Set/7217/faq.html
-----------------------------------------------------------------
Andrew BrackDave

Dave wrote:

He's not - he hates classical music, he NEVER wears suits, and he ISN'T married to a woman who liked in the same way you like the sun - from a distance...

DHP is only type-cast. Would it interest you to know that he was one of the people considered for Jake\Jack\Jock\James - well, whatever the name of that horrible fool played by Di Caprio - pity, they could have won an oscar which they DESERVED....

Bear in mind that he also was in Wolf, Bright Lights - Big City, Little Man Tate, The King Fisher, Crossing Delancy, and in the TV shows (I think that the following are TV shows - being British I wouldn't know...;-) ), Crime Story, Spenser: For Hire, and The Powers that Be (definately a TV show). He was ALSO in the stage plays Beyond Therapy (that WAS a prophetic title if ever I saw one!), Hamlet, The Cherry Orchard (toured Soviet Union and Japan with that one...)...

Niraj AgarwallaThe News Guy(Mike)

The News Guy(Mike) ([email]) wrote:

What different characters has Jason Alexander taken on other than George Costanza? He has been basically playing the same character for the past 10 years. On Duckman, he played George Costanza times ten. Don't get me wrong, he plays a great George, but, on the other hand, DHP plays a great niles.

Niraj Agarwalla -- [email] -- http://www.shore.net/~niraj

Alexander is far more than just Costanza or Duckman.

Denial (1998), Cinderella (1997) (TV), Love! Valour! Compassion! (1997), Dunston Checks In (1996), For Better or Worse (1996), Bye Bye Birdie (1995) (TV), Last Supper, The (1995), North (1994), Paper, The (1994), "Duckman" (1994) TV Series (voice), Blankman (1994), Coneheads (1993), Down on the Waterfront (1993), Sexual Healing (1993), I Don't Buy Kisses Anymore (1992), White Palace (1991), Pretty Woman (1990), Jacob's Ladder (1990), "Favorite Son" (1988) (mini) TV Series, Open Admissions (1988) (TV), "Everything's Relative" (1987) TV Series, Brighton Beach Memoirs (1986), Mosquito Coast, The (1986), Rockabye (1986) (TV), "E/R" (1984) TV Series, Burning, The (1981), Senior Trip (1981) (TV)

And this doesn't include his extensive stage career before he even
stepped in front of a TV/movie camera.  Bark up a different tree, Niraj.
-----------------------------------------------------------------
            [email]  replace EYE with I
          (Hammer nail here--> <-- for a new monitor.)
Seinfeld FAQ http://www.geocities.com/Hollywood/Set/7217/faq.html
-----------------------------------------------------------------
jburdoDave

In article , [email] wrote:

He also had a guest shot on "Remember WENN" last season, playing a magician.

 -----------------------------------------------------------------
-----== Posted via Deja News, The Leader in Internet Discussion ==----- http://www.dejanews.com/rg_mkgrp.xp Create Your Own Free Member Forum

When "Seinfeld" was just starting out in the early 90s, I couldn't believe the same man who portrays George Costanza also played the "villain" in "Pretty Woman". Whenever I see "PW" rerun on TV, I still marvel at Alexander's effortless menace. He was downright scary in the scene where he almost rapes Julia Roberts. This guy can act; no ifs, ands or buts.

R

Mikael WeissNiraj Agarwalla

Alexander is probably the comedy actor with most "faces", DHP on the other hand is almost embarrasing one-sided.

Mark SkrbichJoe26

The Emmys have never been know for rewarding notoriously funny or popluar shows (save All in the Family) I too think Fraiser is dull (most of my friends are suprised at this as they think it would be my kind of show) but the Emmy traditionally have liked that sophisticated type of humour. I think Fraiser wins not so much as it is that good there really isn't that many other shows of that style that are on. (in the style ala Mary Tyler Moore, Cheer, Taxi sophisticated style)

®Mark

"This place sucks, I've chewed up the shoes and quite frankly I don't care if you ever get home." [if Toto could talk] "Shove me in a basket will ya."