Friends Trivia #6

In the episode where Ross finds out that Rachel returns all her Christmas gifts she gets, who initially was Rachel's secret Santa???

Okay.. I'll try it....

Something about Returning all the Stuff.... I GUESS Chandler. Rachel's secret Santa means the Person who gets HER a present, right?

You're right about what a secret santa is, but you haven't guessed the correct friend.

Chandler wanted to trade with this other friend for Rachel, but he wasn't the one who picked her first...

You have 4 more options ;o)

"Jens Murer"

im

Christmas

I guess it must be Ross then, cause he tells him, that she's returning everything. To be honest: I didn't really understand this whole thing... I just know this episode should show Rachel's un-materialistic side, as she collects 'worthless' stuff from her relationships (*lol* You were not supposed to take this.)

"Coffee Mug" schrieb im Newsbeitrag news:ajilbc$rh1$[email]...

schrieb

3 more guesses left!

It isn't Ross either!

"Jens Murer" schreef in bericht news:ajilkc$kud$04$[email]...

im

wasn't

"Coffee Mug" schrieb im Newsbeitrag news:ajiltp$rr3$[email]...

Where is this lormar-guy? *ggg*

Perharps, you could just wirte down all the pairing so I will finally understand the episode ;o)

Chandler.

Coffee Mug wrote:

Phoebe

we have a winner!

"Cookie Dude" schreef in bericht news:ajiqht$fch$[email]...

can somone post all initial pairings? i'm really confused now.

"Coffee Mug" schrieb im Newsbeitrag news:ajisfp$2km$[email]...

"Jens Murer" schreef in bericht news:ajispb$57r$00$[email]...

It's from episode 408 (The One With Chandler In A Box) http://www.thecfsi.com/season4/408box.htm

Phoebe picked Rachel Ross picked Monica Joey didn't pick Chandler

That's what I could find.

"Coffee Mug" wrote in message news:ajiuc2$3o9$[email]...

That also means:

JOEY picked either Ross or Phoebe. CHANDLER picked either Ross, Phoebe, or Joey. Either MONICA or RACHEL had Chandler. The other (MON or RACH) had Ross, Phoebe, or Joey

(Yes, I spent 15 minutes putting it in a spreadsheet to prove it.)

"David Buehrle" wrote in message news:21I79.35193$[email]...

Ah! At least you took the time for it. ;o)

In article , "David Buehrle" wrote:

And then you ran out of time, so you stopped? ;)

Monica didn't pick Ross, since if she had, she wouldn't have suggested that Chandler give the briefcase to Ross, but would've traded instead, and also that means that Chandler didn't pick Ross either.

That means that Chandler picked Joey or Phoebe: but if he did pick Phoebe then he wouldn't have asked her if she picked Rachel, except that if they swapped then he wouldn't have Phoebe any more, but that can't happen since it would leave Phoebe with Phoebe, which is silly; so that means that Chandler must have picked Joey, okay?

At the end when Joey asks who got Chandler since he needs to trade, Monica & Phoebe turn away from him, while Ross points at Rachel, so she must have picked Chandler; and that means that it was Monica who picked Phoebe, therefore Joey picked Ross.

So Phoebe picked Rachel who picked Chandler who picked Joey who picked Ross who picked Monica who picked Phoebe!

Tennant Stuart

My logic was only based on the three lines above it.

Agreed.

Yes indeed. I also made the assumption that no one was allowed to have themselves.

Agreed.

All true.

Well done! (and verified with my spreadsheet now as well.)

In article , "David Buehrle" wrote:

Thanks!

Have you sorted out the poser about Rachel's porno book yet?

Tennant

[clip]

I'm afraid not. In fact, I haven't had a chance to even think of it much these days. As cooler weather comes upon us, I will, once again, be able to concern myself with such interesting bits of business.

In article , "David Buehrle" wrote:

Well, you could always think about it now, then take a cold shower... ;)

Tennant

"Tennant Stuart" wrote in message news:[email]...

LOL I live alone. I have the cold shower bit down pat.

In article , "David Buehrle" wrote:

Awww...

Tennant

Coffee Mug wrote:

I rule!! by the way, would you mind bottom posting (writing your new comment under the old one)? Otherwise it's like reading a book from the end to the beginning ;)

Andr�

"Cookie Dude" schreef in bericht news:ajite4$j66$[email]...

I will. I'm sorry, I'm just used to it with e-mail and stuff.

Coffee Mug wrote:

No problem, this way it's just much easier to follow ;)

Andr�