Biggest Rip-Off of Friends EVER?

Jan 24, 2003, 2:37 PM ET10 posts by 8 postersalt.tv.friends
10 posts
manhnalt.tv.friends

Anyone watch Good Morning, Miami? Basically, Jake (the main character) was deciding whether he should go out with this perfectly nice girl named Penny although he had feelings for Dylan, who was going out with someone else (Gavin). So what does Jake do? Writes a pro/con list about Penny! And while there were tons of pros, there was only one con. Guess what it was...and no, it wasn't chubby ankles.

I can't believe an NBC sitcom on Must See TV Thursday would rip off Friends so directly.

Lewis.

Bryanmanhnalt.tv.friends

"manhn" wrote in message news:...

This sort of creative cannibalism is nothing new. Even Friends has been guilty on occasion. Some people have commented that the apartment search storyline in episode 807 is very reminiscent of an episode of Seinfeld. But the most blatant example that I know of was episode 711, TOW All the Cheesecakes. The writer, Shana Goldberg-Meehan, recycled an old episode of Mad About You, #411 - 'Get Back', which she and Seth Kurland had written four years earlier. They didn't even bother to change the type of cake that was misdirected. I'm sure there are other examples if you go looking for them. Someone once said there are no new ideas, only new combinations of old ideas. The unfortunate part is when they're so obvious about it.

ImKukieBryanalt.tv.friends

Bryan wrote in message

Thats a good idea Bryan.... Lets go looking for some rip offs & post those you come up with in this thread. I'll rack my brain & see if I can come up with any

ChristopherImKukiealt.tv.friends

On Sat, 25 Jan 2003 01:10:25 -0500, "ImKukie" wrote:

Coupling on BBC 2 is the British version of Friends, and they even have the same type of settee.

Christopher D'ou venons-nous? Qui sommes-nous? Ou allons-nous?
Brian GrapesBryanalt.tv.friends

That's kind of disappointing about TOW All the Cheesecakes not being original. I've always thought of it as one of the funniest episodes. ---------------------------------------------- Brian Grapes >> [email] www.sfmwonline.com / www.mouseinfo.com

"Bryan" wrote in message news:[email]...

news:...

Friends

manhnBryanalt.tv.friends

"Bryan" wrote in message news:[email]...

news:...

Friends

What was that episode about?

Lewis.

Supachadmanhnalt.tv.friends

Jamie hurt her back during sex with Paul and couldn't get off the floor. A cheesecake was mis-delivered to her doorstep and she ate the whole thing because she was so hungry and couldn't reach into the fridge or cabinets. She spent the whole episode sliding around on her back on the hard wood floors. --Supachad

Bryanmanhnalt.tv.friends

"manhn" wrote in message news:...

Jamie was stranded at home with a sore back. She intercepts a cheesecake intended for the snooty British neighbors across the hall and instead of safeguarding it, she eats it. As I recall, a replacement cake is sent and she eats that one too. Later, she lies about ever having received any cakes. For a long time I had thought that episode was similar to the Friends episode but I didn't learn until recently they were written by the same people.

JamesS1889Bryanalt.tv.friends

In article , [email] (Bryan) writes:

Great lines from that episode:

"Now, *I* need to be walked."

(Peering down the hall at the toilet): "Taxi?"

James Squire - http://members.aol.com/jamess1889 IDF Soldiers' Combatant Letter 2002 - http://seruv.nethost.co.il/defaulteng.asp Personal Testimony of an Israeli Refusenik - http://www.shalomctr.org/html/peace84.html
David Buehrlemanhnalt.tv.friends

"manhn" wrote in message news:KBgY9.109614$[email]...

Penny

while

no,

At least it didn't read, "She's not DylaM."