continuity question:

If Carol leaves Ross a year before Rachel's wedding, how is Carol 1 month pregnant the week after?

Carol realized she was a lesbian a year before Rachel's wedding. That does not mean she and Ross were done trying (futiley) to have a marriage. It also does not mean they never had sex again.

Sam Bell wrote:

Did he leave her a year before Rachel's wedding? I dont remember him saying that. I did reread the pilot today adn was thinking of something along the same lines..We know taht from SPOILER SPACE FOR THE ONE THAT COULD HAVE BEEN

S P A C E

S P A C E That he started doing Karatay because Carol and him werent performing sexually in the last 6 months of their relationship so even if htey broke up right before Rachel's wedding or within a month then that cant be possible. Or it could be another thing that the writers didnt stay true to past events.

~Act

In article , "Sam Bell" wrote:

Carol didn't leave Ross until much later than that - she actually moved out her stuff on Rachel's wedding day. What happened a year earlier, was that Ross discovered that Carol was a lesbian, and he wasn't. Presumably they attempted a final reconciliation - which failed, but got her pregnant.

Tennant

In article , Tennant Stuart wrote:

Or maybe they simply moved up the wedding.

Sam Bell wrote in message news:uIwE4.4432$[email]...

hmmmm.. this is a clever observation... maybe Ben isn't really Ross' !! *lol* now that would seriously turn it all into a soap opera.. just joking, Ross makes a great father !!

In article , "Helena" wrote:

Well, he's not Susan's !!

Tennant