Review of "The Last One."

S10E17 The Last One, Part 1liveMay 7, 2004, 11:15 AM ETthe next morning28 posts by 14 posters
28 posts
Dan Silverstein
    	In a word... perfection.
    	I have read many posts in this newsgroup about how
the finale sucked, it was too predictable, how there
were no surprises.  And I agree, the final episode was
awfully predictable for any hardcore fan of the series.
I suppose Kauffman and Crane could have thrown us all
a real curve and had Monica get cancer, or Rachel's
plane go down in flames.
    	Get serious.
    	Of COURSE "Friends" had a happy ending.  You can
even call it the OBVIOUS ending.  Of COURSE Ross ended
up with Rachel.  Did anyone really think for a second
she wasn't going to get off of that plane?  The true
accomplishment of last night's series finale wasn't
*what* happened... it's *how* it happened.
    	The writers stayed true to the show.  What else
can you expect?  They did not overextend themselves
in the finale, like "Seinfeld" did.  They did not try
to do too much.  They wrote a perfect ending, an ending
that never let you laugh long enough to forget your
emotions, and never let you get too emotional to forget
to laugh.  And that is what this series has been about
from day one.  Always full of humor, always full of
emotion, but never allowing one to outweigh the other.
That was the essence of this series;  that's why this
show went out at the top.
    	The one thing I noticed, that really stuck out
at me about the finale, was the way every time the
tears began to well up, a joke breaks the tension.
The prime example is near the end, as Ross and Rachel,
in a brilliant piece of acting by Aniston and Schwimmer,
realize how stupid they have been for the past several
years and decide to recommit to each other for good.
It's a very touching moment, and hardcore fans of this
show can't help but recognize the significance of what
is happening.  Ross and Rachel are not only back
together, but they both realize that they have been
idiots not to be, and are forgiving each other for
all the sins of the past.  This is serious, heartfelt
stuff.
    	Right before the tears start flowing, Ross
says:  "Unless we're on a break."  And suddenly, the
tears aren't tears of sadness.  They're tears of
laughter.  And once again, you realize this show
is, after all, a comedy, and it is supposed to be
funny, not sad, and it isn't just trying to be
funny... it IS funny.  And this moment defines what
"Friends" has been all about for its entire,
awesome run.
    	The expectations heaped upon the cast and crew
of this series for last night's show were enough
to bury anyone.  When it comes to criticizing "Friends,"
I'm the biggest bastard there is.  But I cannot
criticize "The Last One," because it reminded me
what the show was all about.  Rather than leaving
me with an empty feeling, "The Last One" left me
smiling.  Smiling because I have seven (and soon
to be ten) seasons of this show on DVD, and I
can enjoy them forever.  Smiling because next
season we'll have "Joey," and for some
reason I am beginning to have hope that "Joey"
might actually succeed.  Smiling because rather
than try to overextend itself, try to force
unnecessary surprise twists into the plot, try
to be something it was not, "The Last One"
provided the perfect final chapter to ten
years of Thursday nights.
    	Deep down, we all knew where this show
was headed.  We all knew Joey would end up in
Hollywood, Ross and Rachel would end up
in each others arms, Chandler and Monica
would live happily ever after.  Hell, I knew
it in 1998.  The magic of the series finale
wasn't about the mystery of the destination;
it was in the joy of the journey.

Dan Silverstein

TullyDan Silverstein

sorry Dan, when a show gets a year of hype...not to mention Mega hype this week, you expect more than the 'obvious' ending. I for one am highly disappointed, not to mention all the extra commercials that were added...

"Dan Silverstein" wrote in message news:[email]...

EricTully

(Tully) wrote: <<sorry Dan, when a show gets a year of hype...not to mention Mega hype this week, you expect more than the 'obvious' ending. I for one am highly disappointed, not to mention all the extra commercials that were added... >>

It was predicatble... but it was a better finale than either "Seinfeld" or "Cheers"... now *those* were disappointments.

stormlanternEric

[email] (Eric) wrote in message news:...

Especially "Cheers". Sam Malone alone in a bar, whoopee. An aging womanizer stuck in a dive with a bunch of losers. That was a HAPPY ending?

I wonder what "Frasier"'s ending will be like. I caught an ad for it...who the hell is "the love of Frasier's life"? If it's some bimbo he just met, who cares? What would be interesting would be if he ended up with Lilith, or even better, Diane...

Christineeestormlantern

I never caught on to 'frasier' except for when the character was on cheers - not even sure what the premise really is but is this still the same frasier crane who was married to lilith and engaged to diane or did they eliminate all that when they made the spin off? -- Christine

[GH]BABB: Keeping the World Safe from Sage and Emily

"I'm sure that, in time, her death will be a mystery even to me." "Mama's little baby loves short'nin short'nin, mamas little baby loves short'nin bread"

Christina in GAstormlantern

"stormlantern" wrote in message news:[email]...

news:...

Kelsey Grammar has said that he would like to end up with Lilith in the end but I don't believe that is going to happen. I don't know who the woman is that he's in love with. I'm just happy for Niles and Daphne :)

Christina in GA

Danstormlantern

On 9 May 2004 01:40:10 -0700, [email] (stormlantern) wrote:

THAT would have been awesome.

Dan SilversteinTully

"Tully" wrote in news:mGOmc.45238$0H1.4254293@attbi_s54:

Why break from a formula that has been successful for a decade in order to satisfy a small fraction of your core audience? I respect the writers for staying true to the series. Rather than try to distinguish the last episode by deviating from the first 235 episodes, they kept right in stride with what had worked over the years. Yes, it was predictable this way, but to me, and to the majority of hard-core fans that I have spoken to about this, it was far more satisfying.

Dan

MoBay4Dan Silverstein

I totally agree -- geez, folks, it IS a comedy and has been enjoyable. Sometimes I can get critical and see things wrong with the script or the set or even the acting, but SO WHAT! I still find myself laughing out loud and enjoying the show. No need to make it more than it is or expect it to be more than it is. Friends is simply a situation comedy and should be enjoyed as such.

Stephanie @}-`-,---- "Dan Silverstein" wrote in message news:[email]...
cookie dudeDan Silverstein

Dan Silverstein wrote:

Even though I cut most of your review, I wholeheartedly agree about the finale. It wrapped up everything quite nicely and it was enjoyable. I meant to start with the clip show, but I got so sucked in that it took 30 minutes before I realised that maybe I was actually watching /The last one/ and not the clip show :) My only complaint is the road the Friends travelled to get to this point. There were some major letdowns in recent shows, but I don't feel like bitching right now, I'd rather sit back and remember all those great times we've had with "our" Friends :-)

In the year 2000... "Rather than waste time with an office visit, Christina Aguilera will send her gynecologist a copy of her latest video." http://fear.mybigmouth.com
MauiJNPDan Silverstein

while I thought this show was better than most finales, I did not like how it left Joey out. everyone else got their stuff together and we know where they will be in five years.....married with kids. poor joey had nothing. even if this was because he is getting a spinoff, I still think they should have done something with him.

here's what I wanted to see.........

monica and chandler have a baby and get their house only to find out they were pregnant. then they would have one baby and one of the way. i alos would have liked them to get a boy and name him Daniel (like she said when emma was born).

phoebe and mike plan to start a family and just be happy together.

ross and rachel move to paris together, then she can take the job and they can be together.

joey to move in with monica and chandler. this would have had closure but also set up his sitcom because then he would be able to say that after staying with them and the kid he decided to finally try out his dreams in hollywood.

Dan SilversteinMauiJNP

"MauiJNP" wrote in news:[email]:

I actually liked that Joey was not given an "ending," simply because we all know that his story is NOT ending. His ending will come eventually, I'm sure... hopefully in about ten years. :)

DanMauiJNP

On Fri, 7 May 2004 16:55:45 -0400, "MauiJNP" wrote:

That a major cliche.

I kind of expected that to happen since there was no reason for Ross not being able to move to Paris other than Ben.

Don't agree with that one. Joey needs to grow up some time.

Lydia MDan Silverstein

Dan Silverstein wrote in message news:...

My expectation leading up to the finale wasn't high it pretty much
summed up season 10.   However, I did find the acting on the finale to
be quite poor. it's as if they were all very distracted somehow and
wanted to get it over with.  R&R ended up together at the second last
act before the final scene and not a moment sooner.  Ross even
mentioned we were on a break.  Somehow the entire R&R story in the
finale came across as contrived and forced.   Was this satisfying I
can't say.  Wonder what R&R fans felt about the episode?

The last act had the gang saunter out for one last cup of latte as the camera pans the empty apartment and comes to a halt with the final shot showing the famous picture frame on the door before fading away.

That ending wasn't so much for the sextet but for the fans. Why would they have to share one last cup of coffee at Central Perk? Are they never going to see each other again? The only ones that were moving are C&M and that too to Winchester about 30 minutes away from Central Perk. Joey would still be in the apartment across the hallway. I know, I know, he's moving to LA, but in the friends world we don't know that yet as the writers made no reference to it. And R&R will be in Ross' Ugly Naked Guy apartment. Phoebe isn't going anywhere either. So that means, Joey, Phoebe, Ross and Rachel will still be able to hang out at Central Perk daily like they always do and most likely the sextet can hang out at Central Perk whenever the Bings come out to town.

Lydia

ChristineeeLydia M

Westchester -- Christine

[GH]BABB: Keeping the World Safe from Sage and Emily

"I'm sure that, in time, her death will be a mystery even to me." "Mama's little baby loves short'nin short'nin, mamas little baby loves short'nin bread"

Jonathan RobertsChristineee

My spell-checker has always tried to replace that with "wastewater."

Jonathan Roberts * guitar, keyboards, vocals * North River Preservation To reach me reverse: moc(dot)xobop(at)ggestran
cookie dudeLydia M

Lydia M wrote:

That I wondered too. Also, a lot of stuff was recycled from earlier episodes. Ross missing Rachel as she just boarded the plane was pretty much the same as in 124 only the roles reversed. The dialogue between the airline employee and Ross even seemed to be very alike. Of course the whole Ross saying I love you and the woman he says it to boarding a plane right after had been with Emily before as well, but despite these things I still enjoyed the finale

In the year 2000... "Rather than waste time with an office visit, Christina Aguilera will send her gynecologist a copy of her latest video." http://fear.mybigmouth.com
Lydia Mcookie dude

cookie dude wrote in message news:...

I wish that Kauffman and Crane could have come up with a more creative way of reuniting R&R. A lot of time was wasted watching Ross race across town to stop Rachel. Since you are a fan of R&R, were you satisfied with the way R&R story was wrapped up?

Joey is going to need plenty of help from his friends in the spin-off. It would be nice to see R&R as a couple drop by the show.

Incidently the spoilers for the entire finale was posted on defamer.com and popbitch.com except for the scene where Ross presumably goes on one knee and proposes to Rachel to be his "4th wife". Even the final scene was chillingly accurate. Maybe they did shoot the proposal scene and decide to drop it.

On a final note this show has always had a grand tradition of pissing fans off. It has always been upsetting either R&R fans or J&R fans with the ludicrous plot twists involving the threesome. Just when you figured with the happy ending they could no long alienate another group of fans in steps the network with its clever programming to screw up millions of TiVos.

At $2mil per 30 sec slot I guess they wanted to stop people from blasting through the commercials. The "creative" scheduling seems brilliant when you consider the DVD will be out on Tuesday. Let's hope it done not backfire should pissed off TiVo users decide to boycott the dvd.

Dan SilversteinLydia M

Maybe this was one of the bonus scenes that will only be found on the DVD. Seems strange that a site would have spoilers that accurate and be wrong about a single scene.

Dan

Lydia MDan Silverstein

Dan wrote in message news:...

The finale was filmed in two parts. The first part was before a live audience on special invitaton. And those spoilers were accurate right down to the lines. The second part was a closed set. So it must have been leaked out by someone involved in the show possibly by a PA. Ideas are thrown up and the proposal scene may have been one of them. The link to the spoilers is below if you're curious:

http://www.defamer.com/topic/still-more-friends-spoilers-from-the-set-001868.php
Jonathan RobertsLydia M

Lydia M wrote:

Well, they WERE trying to tie up all the loose ends in a short time. Then again if they admit they love each other so deeply, lots of other problems can be dealt with.

Jonathan Roberts * guitar, keyboards, vocals * North River Preservation To reach me reverse: moc(dot)xobop(at)ggestran
edLydia M

[email] (Lydia M) wrote in message news:...

^^ This was really my only problem. It was the final episode but not the final time these guys would be together. Execpt for M & C moving out of the city, nothing has changed. Phoebe is still married and in NYC, Joey is across the hall, I assume Rachel will move in with Ross. And why did they have to give up the apartment? Phoebe or Ross & Rachel could have moved in. They played out the finale like they would never, ever be seeing each other again.

There is no reason why on 'Joey', we can't have occasional visits to boost ratings. Because LeBlanc's track record on sitcoms is not good. But by now he has enough star power to make it work.

Christina in GAed

"ed" wrote in message news:[email]...

news:...

news:...

And

Monica asked Ross if he still wanted the apartment - I think it was 2 weeks ago - because it was still in Nana's name and he turned it down, I don't remember why. So since Ross didn't want it and I guess it needed to be in the family to keep the rent control then the apartment was gone - and probably was immediately rented for 4x what it had been rented for. I guess Phoebe and Mike had their own place and Ross liked his place across the street so Rachel would move in with him and Joey would be in the building alone.

Christina in GA

edChristina in GA

"Christina in GA" wrote in message news:...

Must have missed that line.

Lydia Med

[email] (ed) wrote in message news:...

You have to look at the subtext. That was where I made the mistake too. The finale may not have been inspired or jaw dropping but it was clever. The foosball table that represents Joey and Chandler's adolescence and youthfulness is destroyed. Monica and Chandler's priority is now the twins. Ross finally seizes the day and reveals to Rachel his true feelings. In the past it was either Ross finding out or Rachel finding out. Rachel often indecisive finally makes a decision to be with Ross and not let anything get in the way of that relationship. That apartment where they had shared so many moments together is now empty.

It was about life's passage. That surrogate family disbands as everyone comes of age. Commitment, marriages and babies. They sprout and form their own family nucleus. Even the song that played in the closing scene "Embryonic Journey" was appropriate. They can no longer be stuck in 2nd gear. No longer spend idle time at Central Perk caffeinated. It was time for everyone to move on. The dynamics of their relationship will change over time. That urban tribe they once were a part of will forever be gone.

DanLydia M

On 8 May 2004 05:41:51 -0700, [email] (Lydia M) wrote:

Although I wouldn't say the acting was poor, I also felt like they wanted to get it over with. I also behave like that when I'm close to the end of something, such as a long, arduous project. When you see the end is near you tend to lose focus and want to get to the next thing.

Paul HyettDan Silverstein

In alt.tv.friends on Fri, 7 May 2004, Dan Silverstein wrote :

Or a good facsimile. :)

Not me.

Agreed.

Well... it did have its bad patches in later seasons, so I wouldn't say that unreservedly.

I think that was partly a joke by Ross, but also partly a test to see if she'd *really* put that behind her.

Along with a sense of melancholy though.

Just S10 to come for me.

I retain a healthy scepticism though.

Exactly!

Paul 'US Sitcom Fan' Hyett
DanDan Silverstein

On Fri, 07 May 2004 15:15:27 GMT, Dan Silverstein wrote:

Nice post.