"That was the first time I ever heard that miserable excuse for hackneyed formula writing. Our hero wouldn't act that way. Our lead won't allow her character to act that way. Our people wouldn't act that way.
"No, indeed not. What they *can* do is act the same damned predictable way each and every week, in each and every new situation. Never mind that human beings are irrational and unpredictable and an amalgam of good and bad and smart and dumb, never mind that the most universal reason that most of us do *any*thing, even if it gets us in trouble or messes is up, is that It Seemed Like a Good Idea at the Time. Never mind that making these characters unchanging gave them about as much depth as a saucer of oatmeal...." -- Harlan Ellison, _The City on the Edge of Forever_
I can remember a time when *all* TV characters *always* acted safely and reliably and predictably In Character. When they *never* strayed outside the bounds written for them in the series "bible." When they *never* threatened viewer comprehension by doing uncomfortable disturbing things like changing, or growing, or developing.
Ah, the Good Old Days. When Beaver Cleaver grew from first grade to junior high without *ever* getting the idea that Eddie Haskell was a jerk. When the Clampetts lived for nine years in California without learning how to use a washer-dryer or get the livestock out of the house. When Laura Ingalls, being a Good Girl, *always* gave Nellie Olesen the benefit of the doubt every time Nellie said "Honest, I'm sorry I was so mean, I really want to be *friends*" -- even though Nellie had demonstrated regularly for *years* that her ultimate aim was *always* either to further her own ends or to publicly humiliate Laura.
Yeah, the Good Old Days. Why don't they do shows like *that* any more?
Could it be, oh, just a thought here, because they're STUPID?
For Beaver to ever believe *anything* Eddie said was STUPID. For the Clampetts to live in an upscale suburb for nine years without learning even the faintest basics about modern life was STUPID. For Laura to keep trusting Nellie was STUPID.
Characters who do unpredictable things, who change, who explore, who doubt themselves, who make strange decisions on the spur of the moment (and no doubt a pierced navel Seemed Like a Good Idea at the Time), who make *mistakes* and learn from them, are *human*.
Characters who never change, or grow, or develop in any way, who stay locked in the basic outline written for them before the show even airs or has a single *script* completed, who stay safely within the carefully delineated limits of Our Character Wouldn't Act That Way, who keep making the *same* mistakes over and over because they're *written* that way, are STUPID.
And -- again, just my own idea here, correct me if I'm wrong -- I had thought that the *reason* we like Daria is because SHE, as a character, is NOT STUPID.
End of mini-rant by Ms. Mitchell. Fire up your flamethrowers, folks.
Think globally, act locally. Susan